Great story!

This brought out every emotion in me. It was soul ripping but exactly what happened in that time period. Very interesting.

4 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

A Wonderful Story!!

I absolutely loved this book! I couldn't stop listening to it, and was sad when it ended.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

such a rollercoaster

6.5hrs into the story and.....

oh dear goddess i'm enjoying the book but i'm ready to scratch out my eyes because of all the damn angst and drama. I have NEVER been so infuriated by a book that i was enjoying...lol. Marks of a good author but HOLY SHIT!!

back to the book.....

ok all done. WOW Talk about a rollercoaster of emotion. I think I felt it all. Anger, happiness, sadness, etc...

The mystery of who Grace's maternal family ties was wrapped up in the last hour or so of the book. I kinda expected more from the island clan. I swear Bram's parents made me want to go ape shit on them. Very entertaining listen.

story 3.5
narrator 3.5

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

emotional book

I loved the characters. the story was great. it was a little to religious but not over kill. I would recommend this book despite the tone. the narrator was fantastic.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Wonderful

The story kept you engaged the entire time. The characters really touched you and made cheer for them especially Grace. Well done

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

I love this book!

The characters are loveable because of, not in spite of, their flaws. personalities are distinct, and the story and reasoning was so real that I came to almost hate certain characters, but came to understand and forgive them. The narrator was wonderful, and the story had a way of wringing out a balance of emotion from me as I experienced this story. I felt like I was watching a movie.
I finished the book with the only regret being that the book was over. At the same time, hope flares...there could be a sequel. After all, Anis and Michael need a story!

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

How Have I Missed This?

In all my historical romance phases, I've missed Giltenan's books. Until now. This book was excellent, having all the components that make this genre good. So glad I listened to it on audiobook!

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Highland echoes

I really liked this story, the heroine went through a lot. I became extremely angry 75% of the way through this story I didn't know if I could finish listening to it. I contacted the author she was extremely pleasant and very helpful, she suggested that I would be happy with the story if I continued to listen to it. The story is about the sruggles and heartache the H and H went through and how they over came the obstacles. I finished the story and was glad I did. I will continue to follow this author she is a great author who tries to put real life events in her stories and wants the listener to experience what the H and H are going through. I gave the story 4 stars because of the spot in the story that caused me such strong emotions and heartache. I recommend this story to listeners who like a real life story with characters that can and will overcome the obstacles for love. Thank you.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Loved this book!

Great story and narrator. I cant wait to enjoy another story from this author. Would highly recommend this book.

Love

I really like this Book and I am glad I have will
buy more of this author.