Superb.

Will (and Ariel) Durant’s 11 volume History of Civilization is an attempt to understand our current political, economic and social system in light of what came before and the progression of events that led us to where we are today. This is volume 3 of that set.

Mr Durant’s writing is bright, sprightly and full of the irony of human existence. This book covers the entire history of Rome from its founding through its fall as well as the birth and early years of Christianity. It includes a synopsis of the New Testament by summarizing the life of Jesus and the actions of the Apostles after his crucifixion and goes a good way to explain the rise and triumph of Christianity over the Pagan religions and of Rome itself. The book also includes a chapter covering the reasons for the fall of Rome to those it considered to be barbarians and the list of reasons given cannot help but give pause to anyone surveying our current politics.

The book is quite old (copyrighted 1942) and thus does not contain some information which has been found since the writing of the book, but it is still a wonderful description of the period, the people, their philosophies, religions, arts, writers, politics and history. The book is comprehensive enough to cover all relevant events during the 1000 plus years but sometimes veers off onto subjects that the reader may find to be of less interest. While I personally could have skipped some of the sections covering individual Stoic and Epicurean philosophers as well as the section of Roman music, the book is so varied and covers so much that readers will almost certainly find whatever information they may be looking for in it regardless of whether or not that particular information is normally included in other histories of Rome.

The book covers a broad range of subjects concerning ancient Rome although none are covered in extraordinary depth and the reader may want to pick up separate books covering specific areas of interest to find out more about them. As examples the Punic Wars and the Roman Civil War are covered briefly enough to understand their significance to Rome but the reader may want more information about them than is provided here.

One drawback of the Audible version of this book is that it does not include downloads of the maps and photos that are in the print version and thus the listener will be missing the ability to actually see some of the items of art that are being described. That is not a problem particular to this book but is a general problem with spoken books and I found myself taking out the print version (I have the entire set of The History of Civilization in print format) and inspecting the photos of the statues and pottery that Mr Durant describes in the book and the ability to do that was a big help.

The book is narrated by Grover Gardner and it is hard to see how a better narrator could have been selected. Mr Gardner’s voice is perfectly suited to this kind of book and it was a pleasure to listen to him. With the exception of what seemed to me to be a couple of misspoken dates during the narration Mr Gardner did a flawless job and adds immensely to the enjoyment of the book. I will be keeping my eyes open for any remaining volumes of the 11 volume history should they become available on Audible and now expect to pick up the next volume (The Age of Faith) in its Audible version.

A superb book by a superb narrator for anyone interested in the rise and fall of Rome and the rise of Christianity.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

34 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Only for the VERY interested

Going against the grain of other reviewers, I struggled to finish this long and very, very detailed book. I had hoped, incorrectly, that Mr. Durant would discuss the relationship of Rome to christianity, the decline of one, the rise of the other. Perhaps I misunderstood the whole series. Instead he spends only the briefest of times on multiple topics, everything you would want to know [or perhaps not, as with me] on Rome's philosophers, historians, poets, builders, rulers, artwork, building supplies, or, with christianity, not only Jesus [briefly] but all of the noncanonical gospels and gnostic works that arose after his death and were ultimately declared heretical. The difficulty was that the narrative, the GREATNESS of Rome, became lost in the mind numbing recitation of this philosopher, how he influenced that philosopher, or artwork, or life and routine in the daily life of a Roman, etc. I guess if you really, really want to know the details of ancient Rome, this book is for you, but I found myself, uncharacteristically, fast forwarding just to get through it. I waited, and waited, and waited for the book to discuss Christianity, which he only does in about hour 30 of a 36 hour book..He then goes out of his way to provide an explanation of Jesus, his miracles and influence that is everything but divine, or rather, leaving no possibility that these could have occurred, and that everything Jesus did can explained away "rationally". To be clear, I do not criticize Mr. Durant for not believing in the divinity of Jesus, but he doesn't even leave open the possibility that there can be a "nonscientific" explanation for what Jesus said and did, and his ( Durant's) brief exploration of Jesus provides no basis or explanation for an influence which remains with us 2000 years later. If Jesus was that ordinary, it is highly unlikely we would still be talking about him today, but if you read only Mr. Durant, you wouldn't know that.

Again he draws little relationship between Christianity and the Roman Empire. Others have praised it, I found it, in the end, tedious.

Grover Gardner is the best - no criticism of him. I would otherwise have turned it off in and around hour 20.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

32 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Great, but perhaps the least great of the series…

I really like this series. See my review of the first in the series. I have both read and listened to this series before, and for volume one and two I liked them just as much the third time. This volume is interesting, but covers subjects (Caesar and Christ) that have been covered elsewhere. Thus this volume, for many, will be more of a rehash than any of the other volumes. Nevertheless this is just jam packed with details about Roma and early Christianity. The author is a bit less funny about Christianity than he is about other religions and spend more time on imperial Rome than on republican Rome, but this is not too surprising. I still learned more my third time through than I get from most books.

I highly recommend this volume and the series.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

15 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Delightful Masterpiece

Durant reaches his stride in this third in the series having becoming a master rhetorician; perhaps developed out of his previous work on Greece? It may very well be a better listen then a read!

I have listened to it many times and have added notes as well as dozens of browser bookmarks to art, crafts, architectural and many other purposes. My favorite of all his works as well as the favorite of all my audio books.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

7 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

The Best Marriage Yet of Writer and Narrator

Would you consider the audio edition of Caesar and Christ to be better than the print version?

No, I like both. One helps with the visual memory system and the other the audio system. I like to listen to the audio while stretching or lying down. They are synergistic and complementary.

What did you like best about this story?

The synthesis provided by Will Durant and his assistants.

Which character – as performed by Grover Gardner – was your favorite?

Narrator

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Nothing in particular. I tingle all over just knowing that something like this book and the others in the set exist.

Any additional comments?

I think Grover Gardener is THE best narrator of Will Durant. Please Have G.G. read the rest of the volumes. Thanks !!!

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

6 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Extraordinary History

Will Durant is such a brilliant writer and historian I cannot think of any comparison, except maybe William Shirer and as good as he is Shirer really doesn't come close - just closer than anyone else. Durant not only gives history but also gives the background to the events in such a way as you can see the good and the bad and end up with a truly broad understanding. In these days of reprehensible revisionist histories designed to forward some lame political agenda, or pitched and slanted TV-style to highlight the violence, death and gore, listening to Grover Gardner read Durant's perfect prose, flavored with his own special type of irony and humor, is not only pleasurable but quite therapeutic. Highly, highly recommended.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Start w/Volume One (1)- The apex of narrative history

Will Durant spent his long life on this earth in joyous scholarship with his wife, Ariel , and his daughter. What a fortunate, humble, brilliant man Dr. Durant is. His unmatched style over 11 Volumes and the pure joy of his rigorous scholarship is a delight for any curious mind.
To me, Grover Gardner is the voice of Will Durant. No offense to Mr. Rudnicki (hope I spelled that correctly), but it’s just an ideal connection. Me. Gardner sounds like what Dr. Durant should sound like.
Immerse yourself into a learning experience that will bring you regret as each volume ends, but anticipation toward the next. Start with volume one & I promise you will regret it’s end & look forward to Volume 2.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Knowledge

It’s incredible writing of our human civilization. It truly is enlightening to hear greed, abortion, debauchery, as well as, more positive characteristics were around for thousands of years. The rise and fall of each great power is so similar. The fall always comes from within.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

a must read

fantastic insigth and a must for history geeks like myself! i higly recommend this book!

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

"no use to lawyers and of no interest to others."

"This chapter will be of no use to lawyers and of no interest to others."

This line opens up Durant's chapter on the development and evolution of law during the Roman Empire in his magisterial 1944 "Caesar and Christ." While his tongue was planted firmly in his cheek with that line, Durant produces a comprehensive, literary, often poetic (when he's writing about poetry), look at the Roman empire and the late rise of the Christian Church.

Despite the title, this is really a book about Rome. That weirdo Christian sect doesn't warrant a mention until 4/5 in as the Empire is deep into decline. That's not a bad thing, just helps to know that going in.

While Durant has a healthy respect for the Romans, you can tell his heart is really with the Greeks, whose art, religion, culture, philosophy, etc, played such a fundamental role in what the Roman versions became. For Durant, Rome produced little in the way of original art, philosophy (stoics and epicureanism excepted), or "culture" since so much of it was so heavily derivative of Hellenic traditions. This is unfair to Roman culture in the same way that saying there is no American culture as it is so derivative of English cultural traditions.

Nevertheless, what Rome brought was order, a ceaseless, almost passionless (hi stoicism) march to expand and extend influence. Durant covers this well but you can tell he's not that into writing about warfare. His best writing is when he's describing art, philosophy, or architecture -- all those byproducts of civilization that eventually come to define it.

As for Christ, as mentioned, the Christians come up much later but what is interesting is how the Roman philosophical (natural and metaphysical) schools, as they search for meaning, start to slowly open the door to a monotheistic approach. It's subtle and generally unintentional, but as the centralized power of Rome waned, the ability of different faiths to take hold and exert influence necessarily grew. Christianity being the most prominent. Durant takes us through the gospels and their authors and the historical significance/ background of their various epistles, and it makes for fascinating reading.

While less literary than his previous volume on classical Greece, Durant's third volume in his "Story of Civilization" remains a dense and eminently enjoyable work.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

1 personne a trouvé cela utile