THE BUFFALO CAVE MYSTERY: A BODY HIDDEN FOR 63 YEARS

What if you discovered a body in 1979, only to learn decades later that the person had been missing since 1916?

On August 26, 1979, a family searching for arrowheads inside Buffalo Cave in eastern Idaho made a disturbing discovery.

Buried beneath the cave floor was a human torso.

No head. No arms. No legs.

Investigators were baffled. The remains were so remarkably preserved that authorities initially believed the man had died relatively recently.

They were looking for someone who disappeared in the 1960s or 1970s.

But they were searching the wrong generation.

In 1991, another discovery inside the same cave added to the mystery. Then, in 2019, forensic genetic genealogy finally provided a breakthrough.

The unidentified man was Joseph Henry Loveless, a bootlegger and repeat jail escapee who vanished in 1916 after being accused of murdering his wife.

His identity had remained unknown for more than a century.

But identifying him only uncovered another mystery.

Who killed Joseph Henry Loveless?

And why was his dismembered body hidden deep inside an Idaho lava tube?

In this episode of the Yore Town Podcast, Matt and Megh explore the remarkable investigation that connected a 1979 discovery to a fugitive who disappeared in 1916.

WHAT WE EXPLORE:

• The disturbing discovery inside Buffalo Cave in 1979
• Why the cave's unusual conditions preserved the remains
• The discovery of additional body parts in 1991
• How forensic scientists investigated the unidentified remains
• The extraordinary DNA investigation involving family trees containing approximately 31,000 people
• The mysterious headstone with no death date
• Joseph Henry Loveless and his history of escaping jail
• The 1916 murder of his wife, Agnes
• The historical clothing descriptions that helped connect the evidence
• How investigators finally confirmed Loveless's identity
• The unanswered question of who murdered him

A body discovered in 1979.

A fugitive who vanished in 1916.

An identity finally established in 2019.

And a murder that remains unsolved.

ABOUT YORE TOWN

Yore Town is the podcast exploring the strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Join Matt and Megh as they travel through forgotten history, mysterious locations, bizarre discoveries, and real events that sound too unbelievable to be true.

From hidden secrets to historical mysteries, every episode begins with a real place and uncovers the extraordinary story behind it.

NEW EPISODES WEEKLY!

LISTENER QUESTION:

Who do you think killed Joseph Henry Loveless?

Was it someone seeking revenge for Agnes's murder? Someone connected to his criminal past? Or someone whose involvement was never discovered?

We want to hear your theories!

Follow Yore Town on your favorite podcast platform, leave a rating or review, and share this episode with someone who loves a good mystery.

The story is real.

The place is real.

And sometimes, the truth is stranger than anything Hollywood could invent.

YORE TOWN PODCAST
The strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

The Axeman of New Orleans: Play Jazz or Die

New Orleans, 1919.

A city famous for its music, nightlife, and vibrant culture was living under the shadow of a mysterious killer.

Families had been attacked in their own homes. Investigators struggled to identify the person responsible. Fear spread through neighborhoods as residents wondered whether they might be next.

Then something extraordinary happened.

A letter published in a New Orleans newspaper claimed to come from the Axeman. Its author warned of another visit but suggested that anyone listening to jazz music would be spared.

Imagine an entire city confronting a terrifying question: Could playing music really keep a murderer away?

In this episode of the Yore Town Podcast, Matt and Megh take you into the streets of early-20th-century New Orleans to investigate one of America's strangest unsolved mysteries.

In this episode, we explore:

• The New Orleans neighborhoods where the attacks occurred.
• The early murders and the terrifying pattern that emerged.
• The tragic attack on the Cortimiglia family.
• The mysterious letter attributed to the Axeman.
• Why jazz music became part of the city's response to the threat.
• The suspects, accusations, and disputed evidence.
• Why the Axeman's identity remains unknown.
• How New Orleans became forever connected to this extraordinary mystery.

00:00 — The Jazz Music and the Axeman's Threat
02:48 — Understanding New Orleans in 1919
04:21 — The Pattern of Attacks
10:59 — The Cortimiglia Family Tragedy
14:45 — The Letter from the Axeman
16:46 — The Night of Jazz
22:14 — The Aftermath and Unsolved Mysteries

THE QUESTION THAT STILL HAUNTS NEW ORLEANS

Was the infamous letter actually written by the person responsible for the attacks?

Or did someone else exploit the city's fear and create one of the most enduring legends in American criminal history?

More than a century later, the answer remains uncertain.

ABOUT YORE TOWN

The strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Join Matt and Megh as they uncover forgotten history, unexplained mysteries, extraordinary disasters, and the true stories that make ordinary places unforgettable.

Every location has a story.

Some are almost impossible to believe.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Who do you think wrote the Axeman letter?

Was it the killer, a hoaxer, or someone connected to the investigation?

Share your theory and tell us which mysterious place we should investigate next.

If you enjoyed this episode, follow Yore Town on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, leave a rating or review, and share the story with someone who loves a good historical mystery.

HISTORICAL NOTE

The attacks attributed to the Axeman were real, but the identity of the perpetrator and the authorship of the famous jazz letter remain unresolved. Historical accounts sometimes conflict, and the episode examines the evidence alongside the legends that developed around the case.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

A young woman is found dead. Her husband insists nothing suspicious happened. Her mother says her daughter came back from the grave to tell a very different story.

And then the body is dug up.

In January 1897, Elva Zona Heaster Shue was found dead in her home in Greenbrier County, West Virginia. Her husband, Erasmus "Trout" Shue, reportedly interfered with the doctor's examination, and Zona was buried.

But her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, refused to accept that her daughter's death was natural.

Mary claimed Zona's ghost appeared to her four times, revealing that her husband had killed her and describing the injuries that caused her death.

What happened next turned a small West Virginia community into the setting for one of the most extraordinary murder cases in American history.

Authorities exhumed Zona's body. Doctors discovered devastating injuries to her neck. Trout Shue was arrested, and the case went to trial.

Then came the twist that made the Greenbrier Ghost a legend.

The defense brought up Mary's alleged ghostly encounters in court.

And Mary insisted it wasn't a dream.

This week on Yore Town, Matt and Meg investigate the strange, dark, and unbelievable true story behind the Greenbrier Ghost.

IN THIS EPISODE:

• The mysterious death of Elva Zona Heaster Shue in 1897
• The suspicious circumstances surrounding her husband's behavior
• The doctor's interrupted examination
• Four alleged visits from beyond the grave
• The disturbing account of an argument over supper
• The exhumation that changed the investigation
• The medical evidence of homicide
• Erasmus "Trout" Shue's past
• The extraordinary murder trial in Lewisburg, West Virginia
• Why the defense introduced the ghost story in court
• Mary's testimony and the jury's decision
• The difference between documented history and supernatural legend

One thing is certain: a young woman was murdered, her mother refused to let the matter rest, and a jury convicted the man responsible.

The haunting remains a mystery.

ABOUT YORE TOWN

The strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Join Matt and Meg as they uncover the history, mysteries, disasters, and extraordinary events that make places unforgettable.

Follow Yore Town on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and wherever you listen.

Watch the video version on YouTube.

THE QUESTION OF THE WEEK:

If you had been on the jury in 1897, would Mary's story about her daughter's ghost have made you more likely to believe her, less likely, or would you have focused entirely on the medical evidence?

Share this episode with someone who loves strange history, true crime, or unexplained mysteries.

Content advisory: This episode discusses murder, domestic violence, death, and exhumation.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.