Send a text message to the show!

Guest: David Broeren
In 2011, David walked into his first delivery manager role and inherited a problem with no easy exit. A major Australian bank's business banking platform had been rated fourth of four in an independent industry survey — and fourth by some distance. An outsourcing contract was ready for signature. Leadership was keen to bring in a team of elite developers and rewrite the thing from scratch.

David did neither.
This episode walks through the decision arc: why the two "obvious" options were the wrong ones, the counterfactual maths that made the case for repair, and how he got a disengaged team to turn around a platform that — fifteen years later — still sits at number one.

The qualified answer: Every decision is a risk decision — make it an informed one. The counterfactual is the tool that surfaces what the obvious path actually costs. And when you hear someone say "surely" — back up. That word usually means they haven't been questioned.

Subscribe to The Qualified Answer newsletter: https://pages.thequalifiedanswer.com/subscribe

Want cool merch? NULLShirt: https://shop.nullshirt.com/

Send a text message to the show!

Imagine spending millions of dollars and months of preparation on a revolutionary e-commerce platform, only to launch to absolute crickets. In the inaugural episode of The Qualified Answer, host Simon Elisha takes us back to the dot-com boom to dissect a spectacular B2B reverse auction failure—and explains why the hard lessons learned then are repeating themselves in today's AI gold rush.

From navigating the "irrational exuberance" of tech bubbles to making calculated decisions under pressure, Simon lays the groundwork for what this podcast is all about: exercising good judgment, learning from the expensive mistakes of others, and understanding that every tech decision comes with a "yes, with an if, or a no, with a but."

Key Takeaways & Topics Covered:

The Dot-Com Disaster: The story of a highly funded, heavily hyped reverse auction platform that failed on day one because it fundamentally ignored customer needs.

The Gorilla Game in the AI Era: Breaking down Geoffrey Moore’s market dynamics (Gorillas, Chimps, and Monkeys) and how players like Anthropic, Google, and OpenAI are currently battling for the Gorilla spot.

Mastering the OODA Loop: How to apply the military concept of Observe, Orient, Decide, and Act to your business strategy—and why the "Orient" phase is the one AI can't do for you.

"Buy What's on the Truck": A hard-learned lesson in IT procurement. Why betting on tech futures and "coming soon" software can ruin your architecture.

The Power of Network Effects: How open standards and network effects win markets, featuring throwbacks to the fax machine, AWS S3 APIs, and the new push for Anthropic's Model Context Protocol (MCP).

Resources & Concepts Mentioned:

• Crossing the Chasm, Inside the Tornado, and The Gorilla Game by Geoffrey Moore
• The OODA Loop (John Boyd)
• Model Context Protocol (MCP)

Join the Conversation:

• We want to hear from you! Click the link at the top to send Simon a text or voice message directly. Let us know what you thought of the episode, suggest future topics, or recommend a guest.

Help us grow: If you enjoyed this first episode, please share The Qualified Answer with a friend or colleague who loves talking tech, business, and strategy.

Keep on building!

Subscribe to The Qualified Answer newsletter: https://pages.thequalifiedanswer.com/subscribe

Want cool merch? NULLShirt: https://shop.nullshirt.com/

Send a text message to the show!

Every honest answer in technology comes with conditions.

The Qualified Answer is a decisions podcast for senior technology leaders - the ones who own the call, and the ones who execute it.

Each episode is either a decision case - a senior leader walks you through one real call they had to make, what they chose, what they traded away, and what they wish they'd known - or a solo deep dive into the mental models, frameworks, and patterns behind how consequential decisions actually get made.

Hosted by Simon Elisha - 35 years in enterprise technology, first AWS technical hire in Australia, 700+ podcast episodes, and decades of decisions (some great, some not-so great).

New episodes coming soon. Subscribe now.

Yes, with an if. No, with a but. Keep on building!

Subscribe to The Qualified Answer newsletter: https://pages.thequalifiedanswer.com/subscribe

Want cool merch? NULLShirt: https://shop.nullshirt.com/