In this episode, Jessica unpacks one of the most painful and misunderstood parts of anxiety: caring deeply — and worrying — about what other people think.
Episode Summary
You’ll learn why this isn’t insecurity, overreacting, vanity, or “people-pleasing gone wrong.” It’s actually one of the most common ways anxiety tries to protect you.
Using real-life examples (pumpkin spice lattes, doctors’ appointments, parenting, and everyday interactions), Jessica explains why your brain sees other people as a potential threat — and why your anxiety jumps in to keep you safe, liked, and connected. This episode is deeply validating and gives you a compassionate understanding of why this anxiety feels so intense and so constant.
In This Episode, You’ll Learn
- Why worrying what people think is not a flaw — it’s an anxiety protection response
- How being dependent on people (emotionally, socially, and practically) makes your brain see social interactions as potential threats
- The role your values, empathy, and kindness play in this pattern
- Why anxiety tries to “help” by making you be perfect, pleasing, or the “right” way
- How understanding this pattern immediately reduces shame and self-blame
- A simple reflective practice to help you see through anxiety and feel more grounded
Key Moments from the Episode
“Of course it's natural to want people to like you… we all need people. Physically, transactionally, and emotionally.”
“Doesn’t it make perfect sense that anxiety would see people not liking you as a threat?”
“Anxiety makes me care what people think of me so I can stay in good graces with them and get my needs met.”
“Caring what people think is enough, all by itself, to justify anxiety.”
“Your anxiety makes sense. Your anxiety around people makes sense.”
Main Takeaway
Caring what people think isn’t a character flaw — it’s anxiety trying to protect your safety, relationships, belonging, and values.
When you understand this, you stop blaming yourself, stop feeling confused by your reactions, and start seeing your anxiety for what it really is: a protection response that can be softened and changed with compassion.
Who This Episode Is For
This episode is especially for you if:
- You constantly worry about others’ opinions
- You try to be the “right” way, perfect, or endlessly pleasing
- You replay conversations or interactions
- You’re sensitive, empathetic, and deeply caring
- You’ve felt ashamed or confused about why this feels so intense
- You want a kinder, more grounded understanding of this pattern
Connect with Jessica
Instagram: @jessica_richards_counseling
Get My Free Guide: 3 Keys for Quieting Anxiety Now
Learn When a New Episode Drops: Get On Board Here
Enjoyed This Episode?
If this episode helped you feel seen and understood, please follow the show and leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It helps more anxious humans find support that actually makes sense.
*Disclaimer*This show is for information and inspiration. It is not professional mental health counseling or medical advice. If you're struggling, please reach out to a mental health or medical professional.
Topics Covered in This Episode
- Why you care what people think
- Anxiety and people-pleasing
- Social anxiety
- Overthinking social situations
- How empathy affects anxiety
- Why anxiety feels so intense around people
- Anxiety and perfectionism