Épisodes

  • My Christmas Cowboy Review
    Nov 18 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Amy Acker and Luke Macfarlane team up in Hallmark's My Christmas Cowboy, and Eric came in calling this the couple he was most looking forward to all season. Was it a ringer, or did it get bucked by the bronco? Eric and Andrea both land on a 4 out of 5, but they took very different roads to get there.

    What You'll See:

    • Why the college newsroom flashback with young Meg and Billy made the present-day romance easy to buy

    • Andrea on why the news reporter angle saved this from being a straight cowboy movie

    • Luke Macfarlane as a Texan turned LA guy, complete with the wrong car and a boot full of you know what

    • The aw shucks moments that made Andrea hesitate, and why this beats Alison Sweeney's Romance at Hope Ranch

    • Eric's one real problem with the movie (spoiler: it involves a ranch)

    • Amy Acker, who also wrote the script, and why Eric hopes Hallmark keeps casting leads in their 50s and 60s

    • Three ranch-flavored Christmas picks, including Rocky Mountain Christmas with Kristoffer Polaha and Treat Williams

    • Christmas trivia about frontier stockings, Alabama, and a very questionable Lewis and Clark holiday dinner

    Chapters:

    0:00 Was My Christmas Cowboy a Ringer?

    0:50 Andrea's Rating and What She Loved

    2:55 Eric on Luke Macfarlane's Fish Out of Water Charm

    6:10 The Aw Shucks Factor and the Hope Ranch Comparison

    7:55 Why the Ranch Setting Held Eric Back

    10:00 Luke's Best Christmas Role Since Catch Me If You Claus?

    10:55 Amy Acker and Hallmark's Older Romantic Leads

    13:00 Did the Romance Deliver?

    14:00 If You Liked This, Watch These

    15:30 Christmas Ranch Trivia

    16:55 Amy Acker's Ballet Past

    17:15 Coming Up: The Nights Before Christmas and Mistletoe and Mimosas

    Both hosts gave it a 4, but Eric couldn't fully love it because of the ranch setting. Does a ranch movie pull you in or push you out, and where does My Christmas Cowboy rank on your list so far this season?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #MyChristmasCowboy #AmyAcker #LukeMacfarlane #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkChristmas #CountdownToChristmas #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #ChristmasMovies #RomanceMovies #HallmarkReview #CowboyRomance

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    19 min
  • Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Ep. 2 Don't Fear the Wreather Review
    Nov 17 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Eric and Andrea are back with Mistletoe Murders Season 3, Episode 2, Don't Fear the Wreather Part 2, and they walked in with the exact same prediction for the killer. They were both wrong. From Catherine Bell's wreath maker and the race for town chair to the rooftop showdown, they break down whether this two-parter landed and whether Emily's growing backstory is building to something big or setting up a letdown.

    What You'll hear:

    • Brendan Morgan as Thomas in Emily's past, a role that fits his reality TV roots and his boxing scenes

    • Griffin Landry, Colton's older brother on The Way Home, turning up in Fletcher's Grove as Wes

    • The town chair speeches and why winning with sixty votes is the most realistic small town detail of the season

    • The 11-month time jump woven into the story to match the real wait between seasons

    • Catherine Bell's wreath maker and the truce with her late husband's daughter

    • Eric's case that Sam and Emily have the best chemistry of any Hallmark mystery couple, even over Travis and Amy

    • The moment Eric and Andrea realize they watch mysteries in completely different ways

    • Where people are watching without Hallmark+, and how streaming services decide what gets renewed

    • Andrea's one gripe: Emily winning the chair with a great speech, then giving it away

    • Hopes for the rest of the season, from Thomas and Aaron to Catherine Bell sticking around

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Same Killer Prediction, Same Wrong Answer

    0:30 - The Title Mix-Up: Wreather, Not Weather

    1:55 - Part 2 Synopsis: Clearing the Wreath Maker

    2:08 - The Likes: Brendan Morgan as Thomas

    3:11 - The Town Chair Speeches

    3:41 - Griffin Landry from The Way Home as Wes

    4:21 - Winning With Sixty Votes

    4:55 - Is Emily's Backstory Headed for a Fizzle?

    6:02 - The 11-Month Time Jump Built Into the Story

    7:15 - Catherine Bell's Wreath Maker Resolution

    7:47 - The Best Chemistry in Any Hallmark Mystery?

    9:11 - Two Very Different Ways to Watch a Mystery

    10:25 - The Dislikes and Renewal Hopes

    10:59 - Watching Without Hallmark+ and How Streaming Renews Shows

    14:14 - Standout Scenes and Andrea's One Gripe

    15:32 - Eric's Pick: The Speeches

    16:04 - What's Next: Thomas, Aaron and Catherine Bell

    17:05 - Still Bitter About Steve Lund

    17:48 - Playing the Hallmark Mystery Card

    18:23 - Next Week: We Three Kims

    Did you play the Hallmark mystery card and guess wrong too, or did you have Wes pegged from the start? And are you with Eric or Andrea on Emily giving away the chair?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #MistletoeMurders #DontFearTheWreather #SarahDrew #PeterMooney #CatherineBell #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkFans #HallmarkPlus #CozyMystery #CozyTV #ChristmasMystery #TheWayHome

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    19 min
  • A Season of Promises Review: Hallmark's Best Movie of 2026?
    Nov 12 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Eric promised Andrea that A Season of Promises would be the best Hallmark movie of the year, and then spent the whole week nervous it wouldn't live up to the hype. Brooke D'Orsay and Ali Liebert play estranged sisters Heidi and Sophie trying to get their widowed dad, Ed (James Denton), a date by Christmas to honor their late mother's final wish. Andrea handed out her first 5 out of 5 of the year. Eric explains why this one made him laugh one minute and reach for the tissues the next.

    What You'll Hear:

    • Why James Denton's car scene ("get it together") might be the best work either host has seen from him

    • The Midwest corn farmer makeover line that hit a little close to home for Andrea

    • The "oh, possum" moment that convinced Andrea a gift message was voiced by AI

    • Heidi getting passed over for the hockey announcing job, and why it struck a nerve for Andrea as a woman working in sports

    • Whether Heidi's feminized menswear suits were a deliberate costume choice

    • Eric's one complaint: Sophie's stand-up could have been funnier, plus a line that somehow got past Hallmark

    • Which romances worked, and why Heidi not getting one made the movie stronger

    • Recommendations if you want more sister stories: Sister Swap and North to Home

    • Trivia on Ali Liebert directing The Holiday Sitter, Brooke D'Orsay's nickname, and what director Jeff Beesley says about James Denton

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Eric's Big Promise About This Movie

    0:18 - Recap and Andrea's First 5 out of 5

    4:37 - What Didn't Work: The "Oh, Possum" AI Voice

    5:55 - The AI Profile in the DMs

    6:26 - Heidi Gets Passed Over: Women in Sports

    7:41 - How Heidi's Wardrobe Tells the Story

    8:22 - Andrea's Own Broadcasting Dream

    9:58 - Sophie's Stand-Up and That Double Entendre

    10:54 - James Denton as a Grieving Widower

    11:56 - Ed's First Date in 14 Years

    13:23 - The Romances That Worked

    16:04 - Eric Learns James Denton's Age

    16:55 - What to Watch Next: Sister Swap and North to Home

    18:01 - Trivia: Ali Liebert

    18:41 - Trivia: Brooke D'Orsay and James Denton

    19:59 - A Private Eyes Mix-Up

    21:31 - Next Week: Mistletoe Murders Episode 2

    Andrea gave this a perfect score. Is A Season of Promises your favorite of the 2026 Countdown to Christmas so far, or is something else still ahead of it?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #ASeasonOfPromises #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkChristmas #CountdownToChristmas #JamesDenton #AliLiebert #BrookeDOrsay #GoodWitch #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #ChristmasMovies #RomanceMovies #HallmarkReview

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    22 min
  • Holiday UnPlugged Review: Great Cast, Shaky Premise
    Nov 11 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Holiday Unplugged had Nikki DeLoach declaring a screen-free Christmas while secretly hunting down lost home videos of her late husband, with Juan Pablo Di Pace along for the search. Eric and Andrea both landed on three stars. They liked the cast, the kids, and the family message, but the premise kept tripping the movie up, and the romance read more like a friendship. Before that, they look back at Merry Memories, which ended up near the bottom of both of their lists for the year.

    What You'll Hear:

    • Why Merry Memories, with Lindura and Brendan Morgan, sits in Andrea's bottom three and is Eric's least favorite of 2026 so far

    • Andrea's favorite parts of the no-tech challenge, plus why Sally's mom felt like a stepmom

    • A book recommendation for anyone who loved this movie's premise

    • Eric on the kids' performances and a lead who handles grief without melodrama

    • The big question: in 2026, how are those videos not in the cloud?

    • Sally's password guessing skills and Eric's iPad code fail

    • Eric Keenleyside as Sally's dad, and a familiar face from Curious Caterer

    • Who decorated a cabin that nobody is staying at?

    • VHS trivia, Nikki DeLoach's turn in The House Bunny, and viewer ratings for Who's Coming for Christmas and Adopting Saint Nick

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Stay Plugged In: Welcome Back

    0:30 - Merry Memories: A Bottom-Three Movie of 2026

    3:53 - The Radio Station Challenge and Winter Wonderlanes

    5:01 - Holiday Unplugged: Synopsis and Ratings

    6:02 - What Andrea Liked: The No-Tech Family Challenge

    8:34 - A Book Pick for Fans of This Movie

    9:53 - What Eric Liked: The Kids and a Grounded Take on Grief

    11:33 - It's 2026. Isn't Everything in the Cloud?

    14:13 - The Memory Flashbacks That Didn't Flow

    15:55 - Guessing Passwords Like a Spy

    17:41 - Standout Character: Eric Keenleyside as Dad

    19:09 - Romance or Just Friends?

    20:02 - Who Decorated the Empty Cabin?

    20:42 - What to Watch Instead

    22:11 - Trivia: VHS History and Nikki DeLoach's House Bunny Days

    24:04 - Viewer Ratings: Who's Coming for Christmas and Adopting Saint Nick

    24:47 - Next Week: My Christmas Cowboy, Mistletoe Murders and More

    Eric and Andrea need a ruling on that cabin. Did Sally's mom ever say someone goes there, or did it decorate itself? And did Holiday Unplugged work for you as a romance, or should it have stayed a friendship?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #HolidayUnplugged #MerryMemories #NikkiDeLoach #JuanPabloDiPace #EricKeenleyside #Lindura #BrendanMorgan #CountdownToChristmas #HallmarkChristmas #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #ChristmasMovies #RomanceMovies

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    26 min
  • Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Premiere Review: Worth the Wait?
    Nov 10 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Mistletoe Murders is back for Season 3, and Eric and Andrea review the premiere, "Don't Fear the Wreather, Part 1." Emily and Sam investigate a Fletcher's Grove wreath maker, played by Catherine Bell, who is accused of killing her husbands, while Violet and June try to talk Emily into staying in town. Andrea was sold the moment Catherine Bell appeared on screen. Eric is mostly concerned that Catherine Bell might turn out to be a murderer.

    What You'll Hear:

    • Why Fletcher's Grove feels like Cabot Cove, and why its eccentric townspeople are the reason this show works

    • Catherine Bell's arrival, and why Eric missed her Sister, Sister years (he was busy watching JAG)

    • The show skipping the usual Sam and Emily conflict, and Emily keeping him at arm's length anyway

    • Brooke's total obliviousness, and why Kylee Evans is the opposite in real life

    • Violet growing up instead of staying sixteen forever

    • A serious professional inquiry: is wreath maker a full-time job?

    • Two standout scenes: Famous Ray running unopposed for mayor, and a loaded conversation with Emily's ex (Aaron Ashmore)

    • What the hosts want from the rest of the season, including more romance and more of Sam on the actual case

    • Whodunit predictions with zero screener spoilers

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Eleven Months, Three Weeks, Six Days

    0:48 - Back in Fletcher's Grove: The Setup

    1:09 - Andrea's Take: Catherine Bell and the Townsfolk

    3:03 - Eric's Take: No Manufactured Sam and Emily Drama

    5:21 - Anything Missing?

    5:52 - Is Wreath Maker a Real Job?

    7:00 - Standout Scene: Famous Ray for Mayor

    7:34 - Standout Scene: Emily's Ex Returns

    8:37 - Hopes for the Rest of Season 3

    10:57 - Whodunit Predictions (No Spoilers)

    11:40 - Up Next: Part 2

    Andrea's money is on the nosy neighbor. Eric refuses to believe Catherine Bell could be the killer. Who is your suspect before Part 2?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #MistletoeMurders #MistletoeMurdersSeason3 #CatherineBell #SarahDrew #PeterMooney #KyleeEvans #AaronAshmore #FletchersGrove #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CountdownToChristmas #CozyMystery #CozyTV

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    12 min
  • A Danish Christmas Hallmark Christmas Movie Review
    Nov 5 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Andrea and Eric review A Danish Christmas, the new Hallmark Countdown to Christmas movie starring Emilie Ullerup and Corey Sevier. Marie comes home to her family's inn in Copenhagen, mistakes a guest named Ryan Miller for a travel writer, and builds an entire hygge tour to impress him. It's a movie that runs almost entirely on feeling rather than plot, and both hosts walked away calling it their favorite of the season so far. The star rating still got renegotiated halfway through the episode.

    What You'll Hear:

    • Why Corey Sevier's easygoing Ryan might be his best Hallmark performance, with none of the usual curmudgeon edge

    • A mistaken identity plot that gets resolved like grown-ups, no silly fight required

    • Andrea's Norwegian roots and the Scandinavian traditions she now wants to try at home

    • Corey's shirtless scene streak, which is now two movies running

    • The rushed promotion conflict and a finale that heads for the airport and ends up at the market

    • Standout scenes: the panic attack at the top of the tower and the real Ryan Miller showing up

    • Danish Christmas trivia, from Julemanden in Greenland to risalamande with the hidden almond and real candles on the tree

    • Eric's ten principles of hygge, which handed Andrea a few months of yoga class material

    • Next week's picks: Holiday Unplugged and A Season of Promises

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Hygge or Not? A Danish Christmas

    0:48 - The Recap: Marie, Ryan and a Copenhagen Inn

    1:04 - The Good: Emilie Ullerup and Corey Sevier

    3:19 - The Great Star Rating Debate

    5:09 - The Director Behind the Destination Movies

    5:46 - Corey Sevier's Shirtless Streak

    6:19 - The Hygge Tour That Keeps Going Wrong

    7:24 - The Not So Good: CGI Snow and a Rushed Conflict

    9:36 - Standout Scenes: The Tower and the Real Ryan Miller

    11:34 - The Romance and That Final Kiss Transition

    13:13 - If You Liked This: My Norwegian Holiday

    14:15 - Danish Christmas Trivia: Julemanden and Risalamande

    16:28 - The 10 Principles of Hygge

    18:36 - Next Week: Holiday Unplugged and A Season of Promises

    20:21 - Top Movie of the Weekend

    Did A Danish Christmas take the top spot on your 2026 list, or is Adopting Saint Nick still holding on? And would you put real candles on your Christmas tree?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.#ADanishChristmas #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkChristmas #CountdownToChristmas #CoreySevier #EmilieUllerup #Hygge #DanishChristmas #ChristmasMovies #RomanceMovies #HallmarkFans #HallmarkMysteries #CozyTV #MovieReview

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    21 min
  • Adopting St Nick Review
    Nov 3 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Adopting St. Nick, starring Amy Groening and Michael Rady, is a Christmas movie that aired on Halloween. So was it a trick or a treat? Andrea gives it four out of five stars and calls it her favorite of the 2026 season so far (and she is not handing out fives this year). Eric thinks it might be the most complete traditional Hallmark movie of the year: real stakes, a Santa who may or may not be Santa, and a lead actress who has more than earned the spot.

    Before they get there, Eric and Andrea also weigh in on Friday's Who's Coming for Christmas? with Rhiannon Fish and Jake Foy, and whether a movie about a dinner table can carry a whole story.

    What You'll Hear:

    • Andrea's 2.5 star verdict on Who's Coming for Christmas? and the one song that would have bumped it up a full star

    • Why the Adopting St. Nick poster sells a completely different movie than the one that aired

    • How a small-town hardware store and a batch of Christmas rosettes hit close to home for Andrea

    • Why the adoption storyline and the line "you're special because you were chosen" landed for Eric

    • Eric's case that Amy Groening has solidified her place as a Hallmark lead

    • The two things that bugged them: an ugly sweater contest where everybody wins, and yet another near kiss

    • A standout pick no one saw coming (Andrea chose a building)

    • Movie recommendations: Project Christmas Wish, The Christmas Secret, and Long Lost Christmas

    • Trivia, including Amy Groening's family connection to The Simpsons, plus poll results and IMDb scores

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Trick or Treat: A Christmas Movie on Halloween

    0:24 - Who's Coming for Christmas? Rhiannon Fish & Jake Foy

    3:51 - Adopting St. Nick: The Setup

    4:13 - Andrea's Take: A Bad Poster and a New #1

    8:36 - Eric's Take: Real Stakes and Amy Groening as a Lead

    13:14 - What They Didn't Like: Participation Trophies and the Near Kiss

    14:51 - Standout: A Hardware Store vs. Stephanie Sy

    18:44 - The Romance: Amy Groening & Michael Rady

    22:04 - If You Liked This, Watch These

    23:54 - Trivia: The Simpsons Connection and a Tornado on Set

    26:13 - Ratings, Polls & IMDb Scores

    29:57 - Up Next: A Danish Christmas

    Andrea has Adopting St. Nick at the top of her list so far. Is it at the top of yours, or is your favorite still something from earlier in the season?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #AdoptingStNick #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkChristmas #CountdownToChristmas #AmyGroening #MichaelRady #WhosComingForChristmas #RhiannonFish #JakeFoy #HallmarkFans #HallmarkMysteries #CozyTV #ChristmasMovies #RomanceMovies #HallmarkReview

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    30 min
  • Hallmark's What If Christmas | Watch It, Skip It?
    Oct 29 2026

    We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

    Andrea picked What If Christmas, starring Lori Loughlin and Tom Cavanagh, as her sleeper hit of the Hallmark season. It turned out to be a sleeper, just not the kind she meant. Andrea lands on a generous 3 out of 5, Eric thinks Tom Cavanagh did all the heavy lifting, and both of them came away feeling like they'd spent the evening planning a charity gala.

    What You'll See:

    • Why Andrea swapped out Double Booked for the Holidays as her sleeper pick, and now wishes she hadn't

    • The gowns and cinematography, which actually look like high fashion instead of a Mervyn's clearance rack

    • The dad math: how is Adam's father this peppy when Lori and Tom are in their sixties?

    • Eric's case that Lori played her big emotional moments the same way she ordered hot chocolate, and Andrea's theory on why

    • The no-socks suit and a fifteen second hug where a goodbye kiss should be

    • The "it's on me" scene Eric calls the best written moment in the movie

    • A rare Hallmark marriage with no kids, and how it compares to Garage Sale Mysteries

    • Similar picks: Family for Christmas, A Dream of Christmas, The Birthday Wish and A Kiss Before Christmas

    • Full House trivia about Lori's real wedding dress, plus Tom Cavanagh's malaria and avocado stories

    Chapters:

    0:00 - Andrea's Sleeper Pick: What If Christmas

    0:40 - The Recap (and That Choppy Synopsis)

    1:30 - Why Andrea Dropped Double Booked, and Her 3/5

    4:00 - What Worked: Cinematography, Gowns and Tom Cavanagh

    6:25 - Too Much Gala Talk and Some Shaky Dad Math

    8:00 - Slow, Low Stakes, and Lori's Flat Delivery

    10:10 - Why Some Performances Read Flat on Screen

    12:00 - No Socks, No Goodbye Kiss

    14:10 - Standout: Jonathan Whittaker and the "It's On Me" Scene

    17:20 - The Romance: A Long Marriage With No Kids

    18:50 - If You Liked This, Watch These Instead

    21:10 - Full House Trivia: Lori's Real Wedding Dress

    23:20 - Tom Cavanagh, Malaria and Avocados

    23:55 - IMDb Scores and Poll Results

    25:50 - Next Week: Who's Coming for Christmas?, Adopting St. Nick, A Danish Christmas

    Andrea gave What If Christmas a generous 3 out of 5, and the early poll is all over the map. Too generous, too harsh, or about right? And did Tom Cavanagh carry it for you?

    New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

    #WhatIfChristmas #LoriLoughlin #TomCavanagh #HallmarkChristmas #CountdownToChristmas #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #ChristmasMovies #HallmarkReview #FullHouse #RomanceMovies

    Follow us on social media:
    Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
    Youtube

    Or visit our website.

    This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    Afficher plus Afficher moins
    28 min