The Sandra Birchmore trial continues in Massachusetts. Former Police Officer Matthew Farwell is accused of murdering the pregnant woman after grooming her as an underage teenager while she was in the police department’s explorers program. New in this episode, Brian discusses the testimony from five people who all sounded the alarm after Sandra died. Why did the state not investigate? Also, the Army Sergeant who also had an affair with Sandra takes the stand. And new DNA evidence connects Farwell to the scene of Sandra’s death. LA Magazine Senior Editor Michele McPhee joins Brian to discuss the latest.

OJ Simpson is back in the headlines after an explosive report from The New York Times that included unsealed documents that bring up a huge question: Was there an accomplice? Mike Baker, the reporter who broke the story, joins Brian to discuss the documents and what he learned about a potential secret informant connected to OJ. Then, retired FBI agent Jim Clemente joins Brian to break down the evidence that backs the theory that there was more than one person at the crime scene that night. Plus, Tanya Brown, Nicole Brown Simpson’s sister joins Brian to talk about her struggle with grief, and how she wants Nicole to be remembered.

There is so much discussion about Christa Pike’s botched execution — but in this episode, Brian does a deep dive into the brutal murder she was convicted of. Not only did Pike kill Colleen Slemmer, but she kept a part of her skull — and even returned to the crime scene acting giddy the next day. Brian will detail the gruesome murders, and exactly who Pike’s accomplices were. Also, the police chief who oversaw the investigation explains to Brian why to this day he believes Christa Pike is “pure evil.”