The Whale Rider

Kahu, her great-grandfather, and the whale rider

I stepped into this one backwards. I saw the movie first, then looked for the book. I read the book, then just recently listened to the audiobook thanks to a friend who had it on her ipod. If you like stories of ancient tradition or stories where characters struggle against ancient tradition, this is a good one. The Whale Rider offers a look into the world of a tribe that decends from the legendary "whale rider" and the struggle of Kahu to overcome tradition and be recognized for who she is (and who she can become). This is a good story, and one I would recommend.

15 sur 16 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

a joy!

Inspiring story for anyone; suitable for "tween agers", but my parents and i really enjoyed it on a drive to California. We had loved the movie, and the book was another joy. The Maori sounding music between chapters added to the mood.

5 sur 5 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Maori legend retold - for kids and adults

A gem that glistens. Beautiful. A contemporary rewriting of an ancient Maori legend. Its messages speak of the strength of women, but even more importantly of the oneness of the past and present, the rational and the irrational, what we understand and don’t understand and of all life on earth. This is young adult literature for adults.

The audiobook narration by Kiwian Jay Laga’aia was well done. There is music throughout the recording, but it is the same snippet repeated over and over again. When will we get audiobooks with varied music and numerous songs? Anybody listening out there?

3 sur 3 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Not as good as the movie, surprisingly.

This is one of the exceedingly rare cases where the book is not as good as the movie.

If you've not seen the movie "Whale Rider" don't bother reading this until you've seen it. The movie is great and really tells the story perfectly. You'll want to experience it first that way.

For fans of the movie, like me, the most interesting thing about this book is how it differs from the movie. It does differ from the movie in some fundamental ways. In fact, I got the distinct impression that the aspects of the movie that made it as good as it was must have come mainly from Niki Caro's vision, rather than Witi Ihimaera. That's not to say Ihimaera didn't have the seminal idea and a good story to tell, but it seems that Caro saw the real potential here. It's almost as if the movie and the book have different agendas -- different points to make about the world, people in general, the human condition, life, etc.

So even though I wasn't crazy about the book, I recommend it highly for fans of the movie so that you can evaluate the significance of how they differ. It may lead to an even greater appreciation for the movie.

2 sur 2 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

It tries way to hard

The book deals with several issues faceing today's indigenous people, but the way it does so feels forced and one-sided, which sort of spoils the point.

1 sur 1 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

The Mighty Maori Women

A beautiful and in depth journey into the culture of the Maori people, and an inspiring advocation for the role of women in all phases and forms of life. I loved every second!

beautiful

made me smile, cheer and cry. a beautiful and inspiring book. makes me so proud to be indigenous. love this book.

Good for traveling through New Zealand

Wonderful insight into contemporary Maori culture and the importance of their sacred relationship with the ancient whales. Listened to this touching story as I was traveling in New Zealand - great choice! Excellent performance/reading. Can't wait to see the movie.