Bill and Madelyn discuss the mysterious Hat Man, a dark presence known for not fleeing when seen, and how shadow figures became a named phenomenon.

Madelyn traces the 1898 case of Cordelia Botkin, who mailed arsenic-laced chocolates to her lover’s wife Mary Dunning, killing her and her sister Ida.

Bill and Madelyn explore weird coincidences, from Mark Twain predicting his own death to the Jim twins’ eerily parallel lives, along with a few weird coincidences of their own.

Madelyn explores the history and cultural roots of Haint Blue paint in Gullah Geechee culture, while Bill discusses other home protection traditions including the mysterious writing on their front door.

Bill explores the two most famous pieces of Bigfoot evidence, the 1958 Bluff Creek footprints and the Patterson-Gimlin film, and the hoax confessions made by the families after the alleged perpetrators had died.

Madelyn explores postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis. Discussing what they are, how they're misunderstood, and how they intersect with true crime through a forensic psychology lens.

Madelyn explores the Body Farm, where donated bodies advance the science of determining time of death, while Bill traces the history of cremation and what happens to a family's collected ashes.

Bill covers the history of numerology from Pythagoras to Doreen Virtue, who coined "angel numbers" before denouncing it as sinful, while Madelyn explores the psychology of why we see patterns.