Welcome back to The Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet.

We start with the biggest talking point as Paul Scholes is challenged on his criticism of Lisandro Martínez, sparking a heated debate about pundit responsibility and whether players are judged too harshly.

The focus then shifts to the title race as Arsenal continue to fly and Manchester City look to close the gap. Arsenal fan Matt backs his side’s chances and makes the case for Declan Rice as a Ballon d’Or contender, while questions are also asked about Pep Guardiola and City’s tough January.

We also look at Manchester United, where Michael Carrick is in the spotlight, and debate whether he could earn a permanent role, plus where Bruno Fernandes ranks among the club’s greats.

Elsewhere, managerial pressure builds across the league with Chelsea, Spurs, Palace and West Ham all under discussion as fans give their views.

Are pundits too harsh on players? Let us know in the comments and don’t forget to like and subscribe so you never miss an episode of The Overlap.

00:00 Intro

11:29 Arsenal are now title favourites

25:07 Manchester City's Recent Struggles

31:17 Carrick’s instant impact

40:03 Is Bruno Fernandes in United’s top 10 players of all time?

43:25 Rory’s Rosenior Rant

59:58 Thomas Frank and Spurs’ issues

01:08:05 Liverpool and Arne Slot

01:22:43 Crystal Palace and Glasner

01:26:50 West Ham's Relegation

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

The Transfer Window is open - so who should your club be signing?

We're joined by Patrick Montgomery - Liverpool's former Head of Scouting - to go through some of the biggest deals in the pipeline in January.

Don't forget you can watch the best tactical discussion and transfer talk every week on The Overlap Breakdown on YouTube.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Get ready for the ultimate crossover as two podcasts collide in our biggest and best Overlap Quiz yet brought to you by Arne!

This year, it's the stars of Stick to Football Gary Neville, Roy Keane, Ian Wright, Jill Scott, and Jamie Carragher facing off against The Good, The Bad, and The Football team of Paddy McGuinness, Paul Scholes, Nicky Butt, Ella Toone, and Shaun Wright-Phillips. All hosted by the fantastic Iain Stirling!

NB: Some rounds in the quiz are visual-based - so please do catch us on YouTube if you want the full quiz experience!

This episode is sponsored by Huel.

Gary Neville and the Stick to Football team know - when your day’s full-on, you need fuel that’s fast and actually good for you.Huel is the ultimate meal on the go - high protein, packed with 26 essential vitamins & minerals, and ready in seconds.

🏆 Exclusive for The Overlap listeners: Get your first Huel with a special discount AND a free gift. That goes for all of their range, including the brand new Huel Lite!

👉 Claim Your Offer Now – and see why millions have made the switch. Go to https://huel.com/theoverlap

Stick to Football is brought to you by our partners ARNE clothing

https://arneclo.com

This episode is sponsored by Sky Bet’s Super 6.

Visit super6.skysports.com for your chance to win.Terms and conditions apply: https://super6.skysports.com/terms

00:00 Intro

07:55 - General Football Knowledge

43:04 - Observation Round

59:16 - Football Pictionary

01:06:23 - Pull-up Challenge

01:11:34 - Final Round

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.