Episodes

  • Ping Pong+ ChatGTP + Hyper Aware + Booty Shorts = ?
    20 Nov 2026

    Hey, Its me, Keith Brooklyn. Just chatting with you and wanting to share questions on life. I'm going to start some solo podcasts on those life questions we always wanted to not talk about, or perhaps obsess over. What is your ultimate Altered reality? Do you play a mean ping pong and how did you learn? All covered in the serious and silly episode.

    Show more Show less
    26 min
  • Elaine interviews for Phish documentary, snakes on Q train, aging out of speedos,
    28 Sep 2026

    Elaine is back. What do you get? Chaos and Love! and Everything all at once. Snakes on Q train, interviews for Phish documentary, aging out of speedos and tube socks- the horror! Nothing else to summarize here just listen.

    Show more Show less
    46 min
  • HS friends go at it, Dolly love, moiraisms, tito and Casper versus marvel
    21 Sep 2026

    What does 40 years of friendship equal to? Crazy friendship love, chattering forever, and perfect bickering. Karla and I give love to queen Dolly , debate whether Casper (the friendly ghost) would get along with marvel characters, and gay straight queer or not debate too of course! MY love for moirasms and love to Catherine O'hara and much more silliness.

    Show more Show less
    46 min
  • Neuroticafest, how slugs mate, potato chips, He-Man and X
    3 Aug 2026

    Sam Siberini (she/her) joins me despite her busy summer schedule of shows- "What X Gave to Me" and "The Hex Pistols" (little Shakespeare) is enough to make you go whaa? And tell me more! (Link below) Macbeth, slugs, He-Man, animal mating positions, How X guided her life and much more crazy talk and don't forget my NYC questions I always asked my guests.

    https://www.instagram.com/givesampizza

    https://tickets.frigid.nyc/event/6897:1482/


    Show more Show less
    48 min
  • Friends for life, friends for a season, mosquitos mating and The Bronx
    25 Jul 2026

    Finally back on board with my friend Teri, a native from The Bronx, and living in Florida we talk about friends. Thats it Friends, running the neighbors tractor into the house, how mosquitos mate and troubles with IT! We had audio difficulties pairing Teri so we recorded the old fashioned way placing her mic to the iphone speaker. Won't happen again I promise!

    Show more Show less
    24 min
  • Keith, puppy flash mob, Prospect Park, sunset, birds n straight guys advice
    17 Apr 2026

    Keith brings Peanut Butter Toast to Prospect Park, Brooklyn and takes in the Sunset, birds and contemplates new set material for his next show including advice for straight guys (don't worry its all good).

    Show more Show less
    19 min
  • Take the L train to Brooklyn for Comedy and Clowns, Lesbian and a Gay Unites, NYC Hero
    9 Apr 2026

    Anamaria Leon (she/hers), Clown Payaso, Performer and Director talks about her unique show- "Anamerican". Anamaria has been featured in the New York Times, Time Out New York and Gold Comedy. Born in the Heart of Columbia Anamaria moved to United States at 6 years old. She quickly enlisted her humor to adapt to the strange, new environment that awaited her in suburban New Jersey. Originally intending to graduated a chemical engineer, her heart led her to take a clown class while at Brown University. She never looked back!

    Welcome Anamaria to Peanut Butter Toast Podcast!

    https://www.instagram.com/anamaria_alegria?igsh=bnVndW9tdzFjM2pm

    Show more Show less
    57 min
  • NYC Spring awakening, Pole Dancing Q train, dolphins east river
    3 Apr 2026

    Welcome if you are joining us for the first time and waited a long cold winter to hear from us!! We basically been freezing in our NYC apartments, but now ready to get back to chatting NYC, Creativity and positivity!

    Show more Show less
    48 min