Christmas isn’t all sugarplums and reindeer. Nick and Mike dive into the chilling tales of Krampus, the goat-demon, and Iceland’s Yule Cat, the fashion-policing feline. Spoiler: Both are terrifying.

Join Nick and special guest Rich, host of The Wampa Diaries, as they dive into the Amityville Horror—a story so full of creepy vibes and questionable decisions that it's basically a DIY guide to ruining your life in 28 days. From haunted houses and creepy priests to poltergeist-style slime and glowing pig demons, this episode covers all the supernatural drama you didn’t ask for but totally deserve. Buckle up for a deep dive into one of the most famous ghost stories in American history—because why not?

Nick, Adam, and Jack team up to tackle one of the most famous UFO abduction cases of all time—the story of Travis Walton. Known as the inspiration for the cult classic Fire in the Sky, Walton’s harrowing five-day disappearance in the Arizona wilderness left skeptics scratching their heads and believers nodding knowingly. Join us as we explore the eerie events of that November night in 1975, the aftermath, and the lingering mysteries. Was it an out-of-this-world encounter or an elaborate story? Grab your tinfoil hat—things are about to get weird.