This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy unravel the infamous "Milkshake Murder" case.

Robert Kissel was a high-powered investment banker living what appeared to be a dream life in Hong Kong with his wife Nancy and their three children. But beneath the wealth and privilege, their marriage was unraveling. Distrust, surveillance, allegations, and growing resentment had transformed their home into a battlefield long before anyone knew something was terribly wrong.

When Robert suddenly disappeared from his daily routine, questions quickly followed. What was really happening inside the Kissel household, and how far can a marriage be pushed before it finally breaks?

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss a case that takes place in Jeffersonville, Indiana — a quiet town that became the backdrop for one of the most disturbing crimes in recent memory At the center of it all is Joseph Oberhansley, a man whose violent past was known, documented, and somehow still allowed to slip through the cracks. After serving time for a previous offense, Joseph was released on parole, crossing state lines under supervision that never quite connected. And in that gap — in the silence between systems — something horrific unfolded.

Today on LOTW, Becky and Bevy dig into the strange disappearance of Howard Eubank

Howard Eubank had lived a chaotic life — years of alcoholism, fractured relationships, and children with different women. But then he made a decision that surprised everyone: he got sober. And slowly, the pieces of his life began to shift. His relationship with his kids was improving, he was showing up again, and for the first time in a long time, Howard seemed to be building something steady.

So when he suddenly “left,” nothing about it made sense. He missed moments he never would’ve skipped — including his own son’s wedding — and the explanations around his absence didn’t match the man he was becoming. This episode traces the strange silence that followed Howard’s disappearance.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss a case where six people end up convicted and tied to the disappearance of a 19‑year‑old Anchorage girl.Cynthia Hoffman was a 19‑year‑old from Anchorage, Alaska. She grew up surrounded by the people she loved most, and because of her developmental delays, her family and close friends were her entire world. Cynthia trusted easily — maybe too easily — and that trust shaped the final day anyone saw her. After she disappeared, her father received a strange text from her phone, a message that immediately raised suspicion and marked the moment everything changed.

This week on LOTW, we’re covering the case of the Richardson family.

In Medicine Hat, a twelve‑year‑old girl’s personality shifted almost overnight—puberty, rebellion, and then a new boyfriend who was more than just “older.” Jeremy Steinke was twenty‑three, steeped in dark online personas, and eager to play the part she wanted him to be. Together, they built a fantasy world where rules didn’t matter and identities were costumes they could slip into.

But Jasmine wasn’t just following along. She was steering. And when her parents pushed back against the relationship, she didn’t retreat—she escalated. Online messages grew stranger, bolder, and more detached from reality, pulling Jeremy deeper into a story he wasn’t equipped to understand, let alone resist.

This week on LOTW, we look at how a group of teenage boys ended up at the center of a case that shook New Hampshire.On a warm May night in 1990, inside a quiet New Hampshire condo, a husband was found dead on the living room floor—shot once in the head, the scene staged to look like a burglary gone wrong. But nothing about the crime felt random. Nothing about it felt accidental. And nothing about it felt like the work of a stranger.

Greg Smart was a 24‑year‑old newlywed, a music lover, a man who believed he’d built a life worth protecting. What he didn’t know was that the danger wasn’t lurking outside his home. It was already inside it.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy confront one of the most disturbing figures to ever sit across a courtroom.

Was Jamie Osuna born this way — or was he made? His story begins in chaos: a childhood steeped in abuse, neglect, and instability. But what emerged from that darkness wasn’t just another troubled man. It was someone who seemed to embrace evil — who wore it like a costume, who smiled through the horror he created.

And then there was Yvette Peña — a woman whose life had been marked by resilience. She was trying to rebuild, to find steadiness again, unaware that her path would cross with someone who saw pain as performance. The tragedy that followed wasn’t just an act of violence; it was a collision between survival and sadism, between a woman searching for peace and a man who found pleasure in destruction.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy revisit a case that began with friendship and ended in unthinkable violence.

Christine Paolilla’s early life was marked by hardship — illness, bullying, and isolation. When she met Rachael Koloroutis and Tiffany Rowell in high school, everything changed. They took her in, gave her confidence, helped her find her footing in a world that had never been kind. The trio became inseparable, and for a while, Christine seemed to be living the kind of teenage dream she’d always watched from the sidelines.

But in 2003, that dream shattered. Rachael and Tiffany — along with Tiffany’s boyfriend and his cousin — were found murdered inside a quiet suburban home. The crime was brutal, senseless, and confusing. Investigators struggled to understand how such a massacre could erupt among friends. For years, the case seemed directionless — until a clue hiding in plain sight revealed that the killer wasn’t a stranger at all.