Our season three finale is here! Patrick McDonald feeds Jimmy gumbo. They also discuss the comfy chairs at Starbucks, Jimmy being the king of Chipotle and if kindness always have a downside. Jimmy’s mom sadly signs off and talks about her trip to New Orleans.

Support the show

Marty Lauter (Cabaret on Broadway, Ru Paul's Drag Race) feeds Jimmy a crumpet for the first time. They also discuss how Marty created Marcia Marcia Marcia, their time auditioning for musical theatre and the toughest thing about being a drag queen. Jimmy's mother struggles to remember a question that she knows she needs to ask Jimmy.

Support the show

Jackie Johnson (Natch Beauty) feeds Jimmy ranch dressing. They also discuss Jackie's Broadway dreams, her connection to the Dallas cowboy cheerleaders and her having misophonia. Jimmy's mom is adamant that he not have her favorite salad delivered to her house.

Support the show

Taran Killam (Saturday Night Live, Stumble) feeds Jimmy spaghetti squash for the first time. They also discuss Jimmy's oddly voiced opening of the podcast, the complicated preparation of spaghetti squash and a plot to steal Cher's chocolate turkey from the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. Jimmy's mother gives her recommendation for hair dye.

Support the show

Andrew Michaan (Podcast but Outside) feeds Jimmy a Lychee (and a bonus surprise) for the first time. They also discuss their love of Japan, Chappell Roan's battle with stardom and Jimmy's rough time with a gourmet sushi meal. Jimmy's mom gives the listener an update on her air fryer.

Support the show

Naomi Ekperigin (St. Denis Medical, Couples Therapy) feeds Jimmy a fake BLT for the first time. They also discuss the insanity of Trader Joe’s, Jimmy’s failure to eat a tomato during a college acting exercise and Naomi’s aversion to cold meats. Jimmy’s mom tells tale of the diner wars of northern New Jersey.

Support the show

Jonathan Bennett (Mean Girls, Finding Mr. Christmas) feeds Jimmy a sloppy joe for the first time. They also discuss Jonathan making his broadway debut alongside Jimmy in the revival of Spamalot, his relationship with the Hallmark channel and his favorite places to eat in Palm Springs. Jimmy's mom tells of her love for Hallmark movies but her disappointment in Lifetime movies.

Support the show

Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer (Tony nominee Spamalot, Hazbin Hotel) feeds Jimmy Kombucha for the first time. They also discuss starring in Spamalot on broadway together, taking a tour of important locations from The Sopranos together and an enchanting evening together when Jimmy mistakenly took mushrooms. Jimmy's mother is adamant that she owns solar lights.

Support the show