This week, we sit down with Dennis Naughton, former Member of Parliament and Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources in Ireland, to explore a question that fundamentally challenges how we think about science, policy and political decision making: What if the biggest barrier to transforming our built environment isn't our lack of scientific knowledge or technology—but our complete failure to recognise that the people who make policy decisions operate in a completely different world from researchers, and unless we learn to speak their language, translate evidence into clear actionable asks, and understand the brutal political realities they face, even the most overwhelming evidence will never make it through the door? Dennis brings a rare and fascinating perspective. He comes from science, having worked in food microbiology research, before spending over 28 years in Parliament. As a former Minister, he worked at the point where evidence, politics, public policy and implementation meet. Key Topics Discussed: The Three Audiences Problem: As a scientist, you are trained to communicate evidence to peers so they can repeat your study. As a politician, you have three completely different audiences. First, you have to convince your cabinet colleagues that this is a good idea, because if you don't have a majority, your proposal is dead. Second, you have to convince the finance ministry, because most policy changes have a financial cost. Third, you have to convince the public that this is worth doing. Researchers often present to policymakers as if they are speaking to technical experts. The evidence goes way over their heads. The facts don't change, but how you frame them must. The Blank Page Reality: One of the hardest decisions any minister can make is a decision with a blank page in front of you, with no evidence and no base whatsoever. Even partial evidence, even evidence with caveats, is infinitely better than nothing. When politicians work off a blank page, they go back to ideology. If the research community can provide even incomplete evidence, it gives policymakers a framework to start. But here's the reality. Politicians don't make evidence-based decisions. They make evidence-informed decisions. There are economic, social, cultural and political factors that must be weighed. Evidence is critical, but it's not the only input. The Six Question Framework: Every researcher needs to be able to answer six questions if they want policy impact. What is the problem you are trying to solve? Why is it a problem? How are you proposing to solve it? What is the policy ask? What is the difference if that policy ask is delivered? What is the barrier to implementing that policy? If you can answer those six questions and frame them in the context of the three C's, clarity, context and connection to people, you will have something powerful that resonates with both policymakers and decision makers. Political Capital is Finite: Politics is a rough business. You only have a certain amount of political capital. If you use it up on the wrong proposals, you are not heard. Worse, if you push something through cabinet and it fails in Parliament, or if it passes Parliament but the public revolts, you have burned capital and damaged your reputation. Every proposal a minister brings forward, they are putting their name, their reputation and their career on the line. That is why timing, framing and understanding the political landscape is everything. Ministers only bring proposals to cabinet when they know they will get approval. The skill is in reading the room, building the coalitions and presenting the case in a way that lands with peers, with finance and with the public. GUEST: Dennis Naughten https://www.linkedin.com/in/denis-naughten-77231112/ The Air Quality Matters Podcast in Partnership with Mann + Hummel https://www.mann-hummel.com/en.html Particles Plus https://particlesplus.com/ Eurovent (https://www.eurovent.eu/) - Aico (https://www.aico.co.uk/) - Lindab (https://www.lindab.ie/) - S&P UK (https://www.solerpalau.com/en-uk/) The One Take Podcast in Partnership with SafeTraces (https://www.safetraces.com/) - Inbiot (
Afficher plus
Afficher moins