Vous êtes membre Amazon Prime ?Bénéficiez automatiquement de 2 livres audio offerts.
Bonne écoute !
Well known for his histories of Norman Sicily, Venice, the Byzantine Empire and the Mediterranean, John Julius Norwich has now turned his attention to the oldest continuing institution in the world, tracing the papal line down the centuries from St Peter himself – traditionally (though by no means historically) the first pope – to the present Benedict XVI. Of the 280-odd holders of the supreme office, some have unquestionably been saints; others have wallowed in unspeakable iniquity. One was said to have been a woman – and an English woman at that – her sex being revealed only when she improvidently gave birth to a baby during a papal procession. Pope Joan never existed (though the Church long believed she did) but many genuine pontiffs were almost as colourful: Formosus, for example, whose murdered corpse was exhumed, clothed in pontifical vestments, propped up on a throne and subjected to trial; or John XII of whom Gibbon wrote: 'his rapes of virgins and widows deterred female pilgrims from visiting the shrine of St Peter lest, in the devout act, they should be violated by his successor.’
Others earned respect, including Leo the Great who protected Rome from the Huns and the Goths, and Gregory the Great who struggled manfully with the emperor for supremacy. After calamitous crusades, and 70-year exile in Avignon, came the larger-than-life pontiffs of the Renassiance – the Borgias and the Medicis ('God has given us the papacy; let us now enjoy it'). Pius VII had to contend with Napoleon, Pius IX to steer the papacy through the storm of the Risorgimento. John Julius Norwich brings the story up-to-date with lively investigations into the anti-semitism of Pius XII, the possible murder of John Paul I and the phenomenon of the Polish John Paul II. From here the glories of the Byznatium to the decay of Rome, from the Albigensian Heresy to sexual misbehaviour within the Church today, the pace never slackens. John Julius Norwich, an agnostic with no religious axe to grind, has a thrilling and important tale to tell – and in this rich, authoritative book he does it full justice.
Ce que les auditeurs disent de The Popes
Commentaires - Veuillez sélectionner les onglets ci-dessous pour changer la provenance des commentaires.
Much of this book was interesting and would serve as a good introduction, though, as I have studied the Popes at some length, I am not really this books stated audience. Norwich didn't appear to desire to emphasis some of the more ridiculous aspects of the Medieval Popes (Popes and anti-Popes, Kings and anti-Kings, let me show you them), which, if I'm honest, are some of my favourite parts of Papal history. The ridiculousness of the medieval Church is rather fun for obvious reasons and also as, ironically, it is the point at which the Papacy begins to establish itself as a temporal power.
I disagreed with some of his conclusions with regards to the Renaissance Popes however. For better and more specific information on the Borgias for instance, try Christopher Hibberts book and the biographies of Lucrezia and Cesare by Sarah Bradford. Hibbert also has a decent book on the Medici, which I would recommend over Paul Stratherns which is, in my opinion, a bit homophobic. The Medici family had a number of gay men, including Leo X, so this is significant.
However, it was a good overall summary of Papal history, but one should always read (or listen) with an open and critical mind.
The performance of Michael Jayston was very, very good and kept the attention very well. I will certainly go through and look for more of his work.
3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
- Neil Chisholm
A fascinating history for all history lovers
Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?
Yes. It puts into context many historical events
What about Michael Jayston’s performance did you like?
Michael Jayston read clearly and with liveliness but always maintaining a certain learnedness appropriate for the nature of the book
Any additional comments?
This history puts into context many historical events although by its very nature covering such a huge amount of time it glosses over many things. It is however a great read for catholics and non-catholics alike.
2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
- Pastor E.G. Graham
Well written and excellently narrated.
This was excellently written and even better read. The narrator was excellent, his enunciation was the best I've heard in my listening to audio books, his pronunciation of Latin, French and even English was fantastic. The story itself was gripping and fascinating and hard tp pause or put down. It was not just the intrigue, corruption, the scandals, incest, swxuality, cover-ups, murder and absurdity of the popes, but also the history and stories behind the history of the popes. It was interesting to know who was pope at particular time throughout history, their reasons for wanting to become pope and head of the catholic church. One things for sure is that the papacy has been one of, if not the most enduring institutions in the church and of theisy dividing, corrupt and nepotistic. If I was a catholic, after listening to this, I'd have to have a serious rethink. All in all, it was a fantastic book and well worth it. I recommend this book.