Annoying narrator, story not what I thought

I thought this was a historical fiction. It’s not. It’s a fantasy and I couldn’t get past the first 3-4 chapters. The narrator has this non-stop intense, tremulous voice and when she tries to change her voice to make other characters than the main one, it’s a total disaster. I might have listened to the story even if it was not what I expected but put the narrator on top of this... no. Had to return it.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Magical Jaunt

I was unaware that Mozart had an older sister, Nannerl, who was also a gifted in the performance of music. Without this novel, Nannerl would have stayed unknown to me, and that would have been a sad fate to send her.

I liked the invention of the Kingdom of Back. I recall spinning tales like these with my best friend as a kid, and our imagination had grown so wild, that sometimes our tales felt real. What’s more amazing is that the Kingdom of Back was something Mozart and Nannerl created together, and that’s a connection that I never thought I’d share with composers separated from me by centuries. Marie Lu created a story that humanized these characters, these real life figures, to where I wanted to reach into the book and give them the hugs they deserved. I have certainly felt the sting of jealousy Nannerl faced throughout the novel. I know the feeling of uselessness whenever you put your heart and soul into a craft (mine was violin) only to be passed over because of trivial reasons. For Nannerl, it was because she was female. For me, well, it’s because I didn’t look the part. So, yeah. I rooted hardcore for Nannerl.

I love finding novels that explore the realm of music. There’s just a special place you can go whenever playing an instrument. You just close your eyes and get lost in the notes that your movements create. I found Marie Lu’s ability to capture that state of mind perfectly well done. I never would have thought that I would like a historical fiction story as much as this one, and I am very happy that this book had the opportunity to be published.

Oh, and if you get a chance to listen to this on audiobook, I’d say go for it. Lauren Ezzo’s performance matches the yearning and wonder Nannerl expresses. A solid narration.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Pure. Powerful. Peerless.

If I didn’t know who Mozart was, I’d never have realized this was a historical fantasy. Marie Lu’s story flowed like arpeggios. Her words reverberated with music. Even the scenes were accompanied by minuets I meye and tempos that echoed its emotions. It was like reading to a music score composed solely for this story. And Lauren Ezzo performed the symphony on perfect pitch.

⚖️ Plot: I was personally invested in this plot, knowing how demanding a life devoted to the skill of your mere fingers can be. Lu portrayed it perfectly, suspending it with sibling love rivaled by personal fulfillment. It was pure magic.

🗺 World: Having read how diligently Lu had researched the Mozarts and augmented it with the magical world that brother and sister shared, I expected nothing less than I received. My only disappointment was that it was so short. It would have been enriched with more details of the period, culture and fashion.

💑 Characters: Nannerl was the tragic prodigy personified. The circumstances dictated by her world and time were utterly heartbreaking. For me, it was also an insightful glimpse into the mental pressures and emotional strain that accompanies the possession of such a wealth of talent, as wel as the parental choices that result. While Wolfgang shone brighter in life, his sister completely overshadowed him in this.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

libro espectacular

me encantó el libro de principio a fin, me hizo pensar en muchas cosas y experimentar las emociones de los personajes , la narradora fue muy talentosa y profesional .
me ayudo a entender excelentemente la historia y eso ayudó a que me interesará.
10/10

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

Entertaining

The story itself is interesting enough, the characters and the story sometimes felt a tiny bit boring but it made sense since the story had to develop.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

waste of a good premise

I went into this having read reviews that warned me that it was large parts fantasy, not just historical fiction. But not only was the fantasy unnecessary and distracting from an intriguing historical premise, both parts of the book were poorly written examples of their genres. The historical fiction relied on foisting infuriatingly self-defeating assumptions of undeserved guilt upon the perspective character, for which there is no historical evidence. I'm indignant on poor Nannerl's behalf at her mistreatment not so much by the character of her father, but by the author. The fantasy was tediously derivative in the Grimm fairy mold, barely relating to the Mozart family story except for a few names borrowed out of context from the operas. And so much of the author's genuinely worthy feminist message was mishandled by telling it rather than showing it. I really debated giving up part way through, which I almost never do, but decided to give the book a chance to redeem itself. Sigh.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

I love Marie Lu but…

This was not a favorite. The fantasy world was underdeveloped and bland. The narrator screeched a lot of the lines. I had to turn it down whenever she did.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !