I love the book but

The book is great but i don't like the way the guy reads this version

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Review by 8 year old

I really like it because the music helps the expression and makes the story real. I like that the end is unexpected. I like that it is a story about rescuing a beagle.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Very touching story

It was a very very good story. I will never forget it! It was the best shiloh book I ever read!😍

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Shiloh 1= immersion reader format - NOT Shiloh 2!

Any additional comments?

The book and the performance are great. My issue is that when the first book in a series is available in immersion reading format, the reader should be warned CLEARLY prior to purchasing additional books in the series when the book is NOT available in immersion reading format! There was no warning whatsoever that this Kindle/Audible version would not be available with the immersion capability; only after purchasing the book did I discover that for the second book in the series - also a best seller - the immersion reading capability is inexplicably gone, as is my $16, given combined costs of both the Kindle book and Audible recording.

This is an ongoing problem, and as much as I think well of Amazon and (especially) Audible customer service, this is an easy problem to rectify by clearly stating on the product pages that "this version is not yet Immersion Reading capable." For many of us, the entire point in purchasing these books is for the Immersion Reading capability - clearly state in obvious places when this is or is not the case, especially when the predecessors in a series have had the capability.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

I want to go home

The setting of the story Shiloh takes me back through the years of my youth in the Ouachita mountains of Eastern Oklahoma where the jBorn Again culture has its own sub language.
thank you for taking me to the home where my heart belongs.

Love the story but this reader was horrible

I love the whole Shiloh series of books but this reader has no inflection or cadence in how he reads this excellent book. Performance was horrible

Like listening to a Manic Drunk Hick

The narrator talks too fast and is incomprehensible.
Speak slooowly and cleeearly please!
Am I listening to a conversation at a rodeo or a book?
After a few horrible narrators I'm thinking of ditching InAudible!

The best book

I love this book it is the best book I've ever read. I sold love to see a 4th book for Shiloh

A happy dog who loves to follow it's owner

Would you consider the audio edition of Shiloh Season to be better than the print version?

yes I prefer listening to the book rather than reading it and taking days to finish it.

What other book might you compare Shiloh Season to and why?

Shiloh because it's the first book

Which scene was your favorite?

Shiloh guiding it's owner.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

yes

A Great listen. read and good time for all!

What made the experience of listening to Shiloh Season the most enjoyable?

No matter what age you are these three books about Shiloh, by Phylllis Reynolds Naylor , are not only alot of fun to read for yourself, but even better to listen to. Having them read by Michael Moriarty is also a great listen. I beleive all people of any age will liten and enjoy all the twist and turns of this book about a dog and his master.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Marty becouse he never gives up.

Which character – as performed by Michael Moriarty – was your favorite?

Marty

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes and it goes very fast. You can get very wraped up in the story even if you have heard it many times before.

Any additional comments?

A very enjoyable book to listen to for a light harted change of pace especially if you love family stories with kids and animal and adventure.