Same story, different characters, new ending

This book would get a solid 4.5 from me in the overall category if half stars were an option. Performance was excellent.

**NOTE** This is NOT a continuation of the original Beauty with her Beast, it's another retelling of the same story, from scratch. Think: a parallel universe where things are similar, yet also vastly different. Despite having the same name, Beauty is definitely a new main character.

What I liked:
-The alternate ending. Very cool. No spoilers here, I'm just glad I listened til the end.
-The sisters are also completely different characters, and I enjoyed their sassy personalities. Again, no spoilers, just know that these girls aren't Hope and Grace rinsed and recycled.
-Really funny little blooper they didn't catch toward the mid-end/end of the book -- "How are we doing on time?" Those always crack me up.

What I didn't like:
-While the original Beauty and "Rose Daughter" Beauty are cut from a similar cloth, I preferred the original Beauty from "Beauty" over this version. If I didn't know how much I loved the original, however, I believe I'd appreciate this Beauty a lot more.
-Another commenter pointed this out, and I agree: in audiobooks, the amount I skim past overly detailed descriptions of location when I'm enthralled with a book becomes very obvious. Robin McKinley is almost as descriptive as Diana Gabaldon, and unlike the Outlander books, which give enough meat due to their length to make up for all the dressing, this book felt slightly too short on character development for all the flowery descriptions.

Overall opinion:
Worth a listen! I'm happy with my purchase, and looking into more Robin McKinley books.

11 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Long and Luxurious

Would you listen to Rose Daughter again? Why?

I'm honestly not sure. I've read the print book several times and loved it, and the narration of this audiobook was excellent. However, it became obvious about halfway through that I've been skimming the longest sections of narration to get back to what's happening in the story. McKinley is the queen of long and luxurious description, but I found it dragged occasionally while listening. I still love it, but I might stick to the text version from now on.

What did you like best about this story?

The world of this story is so rich that you can't help but feel transported there.

What does Bianca Amato bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Amato did an excellent job bringing out some of the subtler inflections of character voice. I could feel the emotion, and a time or two it brought tears to my eyes (and I'm not usually a crier).

5 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Good, but not as good as Beauty

Robin McKinley is one of my favorite authors in the whole world. Her first book is entitled, "Beauty" and is the story of Beauty and the Beast. Oddly, many years and books after "Beauty" Robin chose to tell the story of Beauty and the Beast again. And that is this book.

Both books have some things in common. They are both telling the same fairy tale, after all. But this story is fairly different in many ways. When this book first came out on paper, I got it immediately, but I was Very fond of "Beauty" and I think I was jealous on its behalf. I did not reread "Rose Daughter" again until this audio version came out. I can see now that "Rose Daughter" has much to offer. I think "Beauty" was the romantic ideal of an unmarried woman in her 20s, and "Rose Daughter" is the romantic ideal of a married woman in her 40s.

However.

I still like "Beauty" better.

My advice if you have never read any of Robin's books: Start with "Beauty" or "The Blue Sword" or "The Hero and the Crown". Then if you fall in love with Robin's work, branch out into her other books, including this one.

22 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Not the usual spin on the tale...

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Yes, because all of my friends like fairy tales.

What did you like best about this story?

I like that the two sisters aren't irredeemable nitwits in this version- they too have character and are a great support to their youngest sister.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

A refreshing take on a classic tale

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

I would recommend this book to any fan of the story Beauty and the Beast. The words in the book are so descriptive, even though it's in a make believe place, you can actually imagine your are there down to very detailed elements.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Beauty is my favorite character. The way she thinks and analyzes in the book is outstanding. She shows a wide variety of emotions and curiosity.

Which scene was your favorite?

Any of the scenes when Beauty is interacting with the beast, but if I have to pick one, it would be when they are on the roof of the castle.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

If I had the time I would have listened to it all in one sitting. I listened whenever I had the time. I'd read the book as a child and was amazed to see an audio version finally. I'd been meaning to read it again but with my schedule lately I haven't had much time for reading books. This book being available is one of the reasons why I joined audible.

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

lovely autumn listen

though my favorite is still Beauty by Robin McKinley, this book is still a lovely tale that's perfect for an autumn or winter mood. I have both read and listened to the audio versions of both Rose Daughter and Beauty, amid some I like the story of Beauty better, this one has the better narrator and was a perfect complement to the text.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

An old favorite holds up

Rose Daughter is a favorite of mine from high school, and listening to it recently was a delight. I found the narrator quite easy to listen to and appreciated that she was able to give characters distinct voices without sounding strained or overdramatic. Absolutely would listen again.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

surprising :)

Rose daughter is another version of Beauty and the Beast. This is the second version of the classic tale that Robin McKinley has written. It is every bit as unique as the one she wrote 20 years before, it is nothing like her other version except that it too is a real page turner.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Round Two

My review may be a teensy bit biased because I love Robin McKinley and have always enjoyed her style of storytelling. What I love most about this particular story, though, is its perfect counterpoint to her other Beauty and the Beast book 'Beauty'. While 'Beauty' is charming in its ability to speak very plainly and make every magical situation seem very real and almost plebeian, this version takes the opposite tack and embraces the fairy tale side of things. Magic is common here, not uncommon, and only startles the characters when extravagant or bizarre. I love both books for embracing and adhering to a very specific style, but I listen to this one at least once every 6 months because the author really goes the extra mile in her fairy tale and keeps dipping her prose into poetry. Now, if you're not a fan of flowery, pretty, extravagant fantasy, don't read or listen to this book. You'll think it's silly and stupid and you won't be able to enjoy it properly.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

I liked her first version better

This book is much more mystical than the first. The theme centers and roses and then brings up roses in almost every sentence. If the main character isn't remembering the scent of them, she's discovering their name, finding them in her garden, cultivating them, collecting them, saving them, glorying in them, pruning them, tying them up, making wreaths, learning stories about them, making friends of them....I think you get the picture. So did I. Very quickly. No need for so *much* repetition. The main character and her sisters were well fleshed out, but no one else was. The beast barely got a look in. And I'm not at all sure what happened at the end. Just lots and lots of roses and symbolism. A good read for some who enjoy nuance but for those who are looking for a good story....maybe not.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile