Night School

Disappointing

I am a huge Jack Reacher fan. I usually buy the next book in the series the day it comes out, devour it quickly and then wait impatiently for the next offering. I had been counting the days for Night School's release and bought it as soon as the audible book was available. I can only compare my disappointment with this book by comparing it to my disappointment in watching Tom Cruise portray my beloved Jack Reacher on film. Both just don't work. I'll leave the Cruise discussion for another format. Night School starts with Reacher making his typical deductions as to why he finds himself sent to a "multiagency cooperation school" with two other successful investigators from other government agencies. Unlike past efforts, these deductions were not difficult or interesting. Unfortunately that also described the rest of the book. It plodded forward, with limited flashes of the Reacher I love. I was even indifferent to Reacher's "love interest" that came across as two people using the other for sex with little effort put forth into even a friendship. I finished the book, disappointed that the improvements I kept hoping for never came. I honestly felt more vested in the "bad guy's" plot and future plans than in Reacher's efforts to stop him. Will I read the next book in the series? Absolutely, and I will hope this was just a one off boring book and not a sign of future offering.

48 sur 53 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

NOT MY FAVORITE JACK REACHER BOOK

When I start struggling with a long-awaited book by a favorire author early on, something is wrong. I had difficulty focusing on the story right away. because things seemed too quiet for Reacher's character. I could not imagine Jack Reacher sitting in a room on a too-small desk, waiting patiently, chitchatting, and swapping information with the other two students. He seldom ever shares information, especially about himself, with those whom he does not know or trust. He does trust Garber, but even there, Jack is not apt to taccept a new, unusual assignment without doing some personal vetting of his own.

Frances Neagley remains one of my favorites, but too many of the other characters seem too bland.

I have always enjoyed Dick Hill, one of the best, but some of his German accents were out of Hogan's Heroes at times.

I still remain a devoted Lee Child fan, but I think I want Reacher home again, sauntering along roads that turn complicated, sometimes mysterious, as he triumphs over evil, mostly alone or aided by trusted friends.

53 sur 59 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

So So

I would have liked it better, but the stupid sex scenes had me fast forwarding thru junk that adds nothing to the story line.

6 sur 6 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Below average for the Reacher series. Not fun.

The events supporting the plot were not interesting. Reacher did a couple stupid things (see spoilers). Most or the story had bad guys being “lucky” and Reacher always a minute too late. Witnesses were not helpful, more bad luck. I prefer stories with less “luck” and more smart moves and counter moves. I’m a huge fan and have read all the Reacher books. This is one of the weaker.

I always look forward to Reacher’s beat-em-up scenes. There were just two of those - some local thugs who liked to beat up strangers. The thugs were unrelated to the main bad guys. I’m ok with throwing in scenes like that but I’d prefer more fights connected to the bad guys.

SEXUAL CONTENT:
There was one scene of women performing sex acts with animals on a stage and men urinating on a woman. There were three sex scenes of Reacher with a woman, briefly described. Reacher does not do foreplay. Apparently Reacher’s women are ok with insert tab A into slot B. I’m not complaining - just describing.

CAUTION SPOILERS:
The Hamburg chief of police “C” is helping Reacher investigate. Reacher calls “B” who is in charge of traffic cops asking B to do something. B doesn’t do it and tells C that Reacher cancelled the request. That should tell Reacher not to trust B. So why does Reacher ask B to do something else for him? Of course B says he’ll do it but he doesn’t.

Reacher locates the bad guy’s apartment and searches it with his team. They leave the apartment without proper surveillance. The bad guy soon returns to the apartment and then leaves. One cop “D” is assigned to watch the apt. D calls C to say the bad guy just left. C asks D to follow the bad guy, but D says that’s not my job. So the bad guy gets away. They should have had a team of people watching the apartment and ready to apprehend or follow the bad guy. Just stupid.
END SPOILER.

AUDIOBOOK NARRATOR:
Dick Hill was great - as always.


Narrative mode: 3rd person.
Genre: mystery suspense thriller.

13 sur 14 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Another disappointment

I used to look forward to a new Reacher novel every 12-13 months, but there have been enough recent stinkers that I'll probably get my annual Reacher fix by re-listening to some from earlier in the series. Night School could have had another protagonist with a different name (let's pick Snopes) and the only clue the listener would have that it was a Reacher novel was the handful of "Snopes said nothing" sprinkled throughout the 13+ hours. And was this storyline even believable? I'm not a weapons expert but my first guess is there is no way this could have ever happened, even in a suspended-reality world. Reacher had a couple of physical confrontations with burly antagonists but his "take no prisoners" persona was pretty much absent during most of the book. This offering by Childs wasn't quite as bad as the installment several books back when Reacher spent most of the story sitting in the back seat of a car. But it was close. Reacher fans will be disappointed by Night School. Listen to an earlier series offering instead.

40 sur 45 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Lacking action, too descriptive

Too much explanation and not enough action. Did not hold my attention like all the other Jack Reacher books. Huge fan.

25 sur 28 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

let's go back to Reacher's Army Days.

double crosses and intriguing story, the reader keeps trying to figure out what it was all about.

5 sur 5 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Boring

Have you listened to any of Dick Hill’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

I usually love Jack Reacher and this reader but this book just didnt hold my attention.

22 sur 25 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Disappointed Again

After listening to several of the Jack Reacher series, I couldn't help but notice an unappealing trend. The author seems to feel it's necessary to include a rather detailed sex relationship between Reacher and whatever female is included in the story. I found this story in particular to be disappointing because he slept with his superior while at the same time stressing the inappropriateness of doing the same with his subordinate. Double standard? If I wanted a romance novel I would've bought one. In addition, the beginning of the book led you to believe the three organizations would be tackling the case together, which was very a exciting concept, but the other two "team" members were barely mentioned. It seems the author was too focused on Reacher getting the girl and extensive boring monologues. Also, the story was not fully developed and the ending was typical. This is the last Lee Childs book I will waste money and time on. If you've read one, then you've read them all.

16 sur 18 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Ugh! Love Reacher, Not this one.

Would you try another book from Lee Child and/or Dick Hill?

Yes

Has Night School turned you off from other books in this genre?

No

Any additional comments?

I usually devour the Reacher books, but this one just isn't a grabber. After listening to the first chapters for the 3rd time, I'll return it (love Audible's return policy). The book turns to white noise as my mind wanders off to where I was and what was happening around me during Y2K. After 6 chapters, 3 times, it's time to move on. Disappointing.

25 sur 29 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.