Deeply disappointing.

Nearly twenty hours of unconnected, single sentence interview fragments that are presented with absolutely no context or background on who or what is being discussed.

This is an era of music I love and feel that I have a fair sense of knowledge about, and most of the time I had no idea who these people were and what they were talking about. And even when I did know the names and what bands they were in, it didn’t seem to help the narrative or content in any way.

Also, the format of this book could not be less suited to audiobook form. Each sentence is preceded by the name of the speaker, and no one speaks more than a sentence or two at a time (all taken from separate interviews btw) so it’s just an endless list of names. I think if you added it up, just the time spent listing names would make up nearly, I don’t know, 40% of the book?

I wanted to love this book, and had never read a book solely devoted to this period of music they meant and means so much to me. I don’t understand the positive reviews, so maybe it’s me. But I ground my way through ten hours of this slop and couldn’t make it any further.

9 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Just a bunch of anecdotes,

There was no narrative. It is just a giant collection of quotes and anecdotes about people, bands, etc. I was expecting a historical/sociological book and got only reminiscences from a bunch of people about how great a bunch of other people were. I tried, but it becomes very tedious. It is like being at a party listening to people talk about their friends who you don't really know. I knew most if the bands but it just seemed too insider. Returned for a refund.

6 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

I Tried to Like It, But...

From the performance of the voice talent to the style of writing, I absolutely do not understand how friends (whose opinions I usually value) could recommend this title. It is so tedious and unenjoyable that I’ve begun researching how Audible refunds work.

6 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Revisionist history

If there’s one constant about New York, it’s that everyone always feels like they’ve just missed the golden age.

This book, while super fun to listen to, reflects people wanting to remember their experience a certain way rather than how it was. As someone who lived through this era of New York, playing in bands at Mercury Lounge and visiting Other Music everyday, the idea that what was happening in Williamsburg would be thought of in the same nostalgic glow as 70’s era CBGB’s is laughable . Every one I knew felt like they’d missed the dirty, cool era of NYC before Gulianni. Everyone pined for the days when things were weirder, less corporate. Folks I knew thought bands like the Strokes and Interpol were facsimiles of the bands they were aping (Television, Velvet, etc). It’s only 20 years later that we’re all talking about how great it was. And maybe that’s the point. We took it for granted. Mondo Kim’s, Tonic, Motherfucker parties, the basement of Lit Lounge, the early print editions of Vice. Perhaps it’s natural to want to look back on your era as something truly special, but the truth is that everyone in NY wishes they lived during a different time. 20 years from now, when someone interviews the kids who move to NY after watching Girls and High Maitence, they’ll say “it was the end of an era!”. And they’ll be right. Until the next generation comes along to remind everyone how much better it used to be.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Ugh

So much self congratulatory, patting on the shoulder, we-re-so-important impotent shit. It was a pure act of masochism listening to this. A bunch commercial wanna-be’s frying over an era they were born too late for.
Must have taken a good effort to compile and edit, so kudos for that.
Oh, well...

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Rates with the best rock bios.

Found myself pausing this read quite often to look up songs on Spotify. As much as I enjoy the oral history part of this book, it's Goodman's analysis of the music and the environs it sprang from that I appreciate most. Will most likely listen to this one again, and soon.

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Greater then the sum of its parts

This was an interesting book.

It is almost entirely composed of quotes, assembled together into narrative form like a huge jigsaw puzzle. At first it felt tedious, especially since the name of the person quoted is stated before each quote. This literallly happens thousands of times in this 19 hour audiobook. When I started I thought that I reallu wouldn't be able to stand it, but after a while you start getting used to it. In retrospect I am really amazed at the amount of work it must of taken in order to turn an infinite amount of jigsaw pieces into a very cohesive narrative. This alone makes it an impressive achievement.

However the very nature of this book makes it void of objectivity. Its put together by interviewing hundreds of people who were very impressed with their own glory days, and as such it seems to attribute a lot more significance to this scene then it really deserved. If an alien was to land on Earth and pick up this book to learn about modern music, they would get the impression that The Strokes were the most significant cultural entity in the universe.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Great book, half the narration is great. But...

Love the storytelling and the structure of the chapters. Interesting read for any rock fans or NYC lovers.

One warning: the female narrator actress is awful. The interview subjects speaking about incredibly serious, thesis-level stuff relating to the story. But this woman narrator can’t help but giggle and over-act the written page.

Male narrator is great, affecting different voices for the various subjects with great success. Never hire this woman again, Audible.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Best music book I've ever read.

Couldn't put it down. I learned more about the origins of one of the most important 10yrs in recent music history than any other resource I've ever seen. Immediately joins the pantheon of must-read music books.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Sex, drugs and The Strokes (and some other bands)

Where does Meet Me in the Bathroom rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

This is the second book I've listened to so it would be number 1.

What other book might you compare Meet Me in the Bathroom to and why?

The Average American Male - nothing the same really except their exploits are equal in their unapologetic shamelessness. Meet Me in the Bathroom is a fun listen.

What three words best describe Charlie Thurston and Nicol Zanzarella ’s performance?

Charlie is pretty cool, but Nicol tends to make the females sound kind of bubbly in tone.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

The Strokes Conquer the World (and some other bands from Brooklyn)!!!!!

1 personne a trouvé cela utile