A sharply observed, deeply nostalgic coming-of-age story set against the indie music scene of the early 2000s.

"Award-winning narrator [Bailey] Carr performs the audiobook in a bubbly but sensuous fashion. Her cadence builds as she portrays profound peaks and valleys in the robust storyline... A wide variety of listeners will love the well-developed characters in this twisty plot full of iconic millennial nostalgia." — Library Journal

It's 2005, and Susan is barreling down the Long Island Expressway driving a car full of friends to an indie rock show. Eliza is a surprise addition in the backseat—unexpected, out of place, and impossible to ignore. Their connection is immediate, electric, and complicated from the start, shadowed by the kind of small-town rumors that have a way of sticking. As quickly as they come together, they part.

As Susan moves from Long Island to Brooklyn, from college to the insular world of indie labels, she begins to carve out a life in music, and the future she always dreamed of. Yet the scene that once felt like home reveals its limits, forcing her to confront who gets to belong, who gets to create, and what it costs to stay.

When Susan and Eliza reconnect years later, the pull between them hasn’t faded—but neither have the unresolved histories that first drove them apart. As past and present collide, Susan is caught between two worlds—where she's from, and where she's trying to go.

Moving between the raw intensity of youth and the clarity of hindsight, Long Island Girls captures the ache of growing up, the messiness and joy of queer identity, and the way music, memory, and desire shape who we become.

A Macmillan Audio production from St. Martin’s Press