Half Soap Opera, target audience 20 something male

I'm surprised I listened to as much of it as I did. Getting thru the initial background of parents, grandparents and childhoods was trying for me. Moving on, there are some interesting sections but they are sandwiched in between cliche-like love letters, girlfriend relationships, college kid behavior, mistresses and in general a non-interesting effort to fill out the personalities. The book reads nothing as you'd expect given the title. My review is harsh in part because I kept the faith, waiting for the book to become interesting enough to finish it, and in the end, feel I wasted my time.

6 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Outstanding

A story from WWII not as widely discussed as many other topics told in incredible detail. The start is a little slow as the author tries to introduce the characters in more detail than is probably required. But hang in there and get through it bc the main story itself and the evolution of this Air Force group is worth the read.

5 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

A Bit Contrived

This book was decent. It provides an interesting biography of Johnny Mitchell, who led the group of P-38s that shot down Admiral Yamamoto in World War II, with the exception that it really tells very little of Johnny's life after the war (there is some followup, but it's pretty cursory). The book also provides an interesting and pretty balanced biography of Admiral Yamamoto. The part of the book devoted to the mission itself is well told, but is only a fraction of the book.

Despite this, I found the book somewhat annoying in several ways. First, and most importantly, it is written as if this were a contest between the two protagonists that developed over the years. The book will provide background on Johnny and then on Yamamoto, seemingly leading up to an inevitable confrontation. This struck me as a trite literary device. Johnny Mitchell was a skilled pilot and leader who, like many others at the time, was simply doing his part to win the war. He was determined by his superiors to be the right person to lead an exceedingly difficult mission, and that proved to be an excellent choice. But that's really all there was to it, not an inevitable contest that reached a climax after decades.

Second, there are some glaring errors at the beginning of the book: Referring to the battleship Arizona as a "destroyer" and quoting Roosevelt's famous speech asking for a declaration of war as referring to December 7, 1941 as a "day" that will live in infamy (Roosevelt said "date"). Are these big errors? Maybe not to the general reader, but they are huge to those familiar with the history of World War II.

Third, there is a small part of the book that refers to the experience of Americans of Japanese descent being interred. That is an important story in itself, but it struck me as out of place in this book.

The narration is decent.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Recognition denied

In this age where GPS navigation is taken for granted, MAJ Mitchell’s navigation & timing to the intercept location is nothing less than astounding! He really should have gotten the Congressional Medal of Honor.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Excellent book, gripping story

Excellent book, the author does a great job giving credit to those responsible for their actions in avenging the attack on Pearl Harbor.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Recommend

Well written and voice acting was very good. Recommend to WW2 students/scholars. I could not put it down.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Gives credit where it's due

Overly sympathetic to Yamamoto, this a dual biography and broad surface-level overview of Pacific war.

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Great story of an unknown American Hero

Well written, great story, performed well. Reads like a novel. Wonderful story of a modest professional hero and the team that flew the mission to kill Yamamoto.

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

A Masterful Retelling of Important American History!!

America will repeat the mistakes of the past if we fail to learn from the earlier heroes who fought for us and stopped tyranny!

Outstanding read!

Loved it! It could only have been better if Naval Aviators had done it.....really detailed and excellent look at two great men inexorbly approaching their fate.