In this episode, we explore Woody Allen’s Manhattan (1979) — a film as visually elegant as it is morally unsettled. Shot in luminous black and white and underscored by George Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue, Manhattan presents New York City as both a romantic fantasy and a psychological refuge. But beneath its beauty lies a deeper inquiry into taste, power, maturity, and the stories people tell themselves to feel significant.

We examine Allen’s shift from gag-driven comedy to self-conscious artistry, his collaboration with cinematographer Gordon Willis, and the deliberate construction of Manhattan as an idea rather than a documentary reality. Through scene analysis and cultural context, we unpack the film’s depiction of intellectual elitism, emotional immaturity, and the uneasy relationship between aesthetics and ethics.

The episode also confronts the film’s most controversial element — the relationship between Isaac and Tracy — exploring how the narrative frames desire, age, and power, and how modern audiences reassess the film differently from its 1979 reception. Drawing on documented reflections from Allen, contemporary critics, and later scholarship, this deep dive treats Manhattan not simply as a romantic comedy, but as a portrait of artistic ambition and moral ambiguity.

A film about loving cities, fearing mediocrity, and mistaking sensitivity for integrity, Manhattan remains both beautiful and complicated — and in this episode, we take the time to examine why.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.