A Reprieve Amidst Ugly News, Relentless Negativity

I am so glad I eventually clicked on this book. I had not read Rules of Civility, but was looking for something uplifting for easy summer reading and the description seemed to fit. What I received instead was a masterpiece which carried me to another place and time, only to remind me of the quiet goodness and dignity of everyday people in ordinary life, whom I encounter daily.

What first struck me, however, was the beautiful language. Lyrical and complex- yet so easy to read. It feels more like a conversation with the author, than a novel. The main character is both prodigious and ordinary. He speaks with the authority of royalty, yet feels at times like your grandfather who wants to share his hard fought wisdom. We are with him through tumultuous changes as he realizes the folly of the comfort found in heirlooms and traditions that are passed from generation to generation, objects that lead us to believe that 'the passing of an era would indeed be glacial.' Instead, political upheaval in Russia forces Alexander Rostov to acknowledge old ideas can be swept away in an instant--especially when the 'men in charge distrust any form of hesitation, or nuance, and who prize self-assurance above all'. He finds himself among the 'humbled', those who 'greet adulation with caution, ambition with sympathy, and condescension with an inward smile'. We follow the life of this man as he resolves that small actions can restore a sense of order.

The plot does just what it should, it twists and turns, surprises and satisfies; but this is so much more than good story telling. It's the rare book that causes you to slow down as you approach the last chapters, to feel like a friend has moved away when you turn the last page, and make the next book you start just a little harder to get into.

Lastly, the narration is perfectly matched to the story. I've listened to audio books since 1998, this is probably my favorite narrator. If you're old enough to know--he's something like Mr. French meets Shelby Foote (without the southern accent). If that's a meaningless reference to you, just know this narration is sublime and somehow articulates the inward smile and humble brilliance that is Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov.

280 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Brilliant, heartfelt, inspiring

The prose is elegant, the performance masterful, and the wisdom of the words something to consider, reconsider and cherish. But I will admit, when I first started listening, I had no idea where the story was going -- nor any idea of where its main character and his friends would take me. I'm so glad I persevered through the first hour, because it's turned out to be the best book I've "read" or listened to in decades -- and I read a lot. For those who like to savor life, it is a must read.

208 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Leisurely, literary, and wonderful

This is the kind of book that leaves me with a "book hangover", and that's just about the highest praise I can give. It's one of those totally immersive stories that pulls the reader /listener into its world and characters. This book is a delight, beautifully written and perfectly narrated by Nicholas Guy Smith. I wish I could dine with gentleman Alexander Rostov !

174 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

A Memory of a Time of Civility

Would you listen to A Gentleman in Moscow again? Why?

From the first dramatic opening of A Gentleman in Moscow when Count Rostov is sentenced to house arrest in the fabulous Metropole Hotel, we are introduced to a time when language mattered, people spoke to each other in civil terms, and fine art, music, and literature were important. Through each scene we live with the count as he actually EXPERIENCES time--not simply moving through it to get to the next moment--but living each sense--the taste of food, the emotion of a piece of music, the deep ideas of literature and philosophy through which he views his world. He promises himself at the start of his unique arrest that he will not have events make him, rather, he will make the events of his life and so rule in the time he has. One wonders at the beginning how a man will Iive in a hotel without stepping from it. The author, Amor Towels, takes the reader day by day through the creation of a world that is narrow, but full and rich. In fact, although most of us have freedom of movement, there is little that we have in our lives that Rostov does not find in the hotel--and perhaps more. The reading by Nicholas Guy Smith is absolutely superb, catching every nuance of the author--the character's dignity, his questions of life, his search for the Russian soul, the importance of the friendships in his life, his concerns and fears. I never wanted this story to end, because when reading it, I felt the slowed down moments of my own life, with all the simple pleasures we take for granted.

148 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

An Overly Gentle Story

The narration for this book was beautifully done with great inflection, timing and good definition between the characters. It made it possible for me to complete 18 hours of listening to what in the end was a slow and plodding story.

To me, this book fit far more clearly into the romance fiction genre than a firmer historic fiction genre. The writing while good was so gently done that I fear much of the drama, violence and history of the time were lost in the storytelling.

Be aware, if you are looking for action, an accurate capture of historic events and an edge of your seat pace you won't find it here. Rather, what you will find is history by candle light--filtered through a gauze made up of an elegant hotel, vintage wine and gourmet dining--night after night after night. Very little will disturb or distress a gentle listener. At the same time very little will enlighten and expand the listener's understanding of the Russian Revolution and its aftermath into the Soviet Era.

I have to admit that while being beguiled by the narration I was at the same time disappointed by the feeling of fantasy and unreality of it all. Really, in the end, it was history lite with most of the nasty bits removed. Recommended only if you like gentle stories that please, but rest ever so lightly on fact, probability and history.

112 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Memorable novel

I liked this novel quite a bit, and loved many parts of it. I can see why this is a favorite of so many readers. That said, it is not for everyone. This is the story of a count in czarist Russia who returns after the Russian revolution. The count is put under indefinite house arrest in a tiny room of a fancy Moscow hotel. He chooses to live with dignity under the circumstances. This novel covers the 30 or so years that follow. This is a long novel, and the first half moves at a glacial pace. I'm glad that many reviewers warned me that the start was a bit slow. That is an understatement. The second half picks up to a slow/moderate pace. Yet, even at its slowest, this book was engaging. The writing is so amazing (and the reader was great). I so enjoyed listening to each sentence. The main character came so alive to me. I felt like I was living his life in a way that is rare in novels. I have always had an interest in Russia and the Soviet Union, and so I enjoyed the setting. The novel really began to engage me when the count befriended a 9 year old girl who lived in the hotel. His relationship with another child many years later was the one that was the most moving. This novel captures the dying aristocracy of a changing era, a theme that captivated many in Downton Abbey. To me, this was refreshingly original. The slow pace was needed for this story, yet there were times when I wanted it to move forward. I, unlike most readers, did not love the ending, but no spoilers here. I recommend this novel to readers who appreciate great literature and have an interest in the place and era.

88 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

A vacation for your mind!

I was looking for a book to take my mind off of all the stress of the news. This book was perfect! I was so sad to have it end. It immediately relaxed me..held my attention and had me smiling through out. I can't recommend it more highly!

71 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Best Book This Year

If you could sum up A Gentleman in Moscow in three words, what would they be?

Masterful, Charming, Engrossing

What other book might you compare A Gentleman in Moscow to and why?

I can't think of any. Having said that, one of the best things in this book is the way that the characterization, which is rich, drives an excellent plot. I loved the characters and I miss them now that the book is behind me. This book makes excellent points about Soviet Russia, without preaching anything at all.

Which scene was your favorite?

There are so many terrific scenes that this is impossible to say, especially if one does not wish to give anything important away. The ending is magnificent, but how terrible to describe it and ruin the book for others! The Count's relationship with his young friend yields some real amusement in several scenes, in particular the one in which she comes up to him in the hotel restaurant and asks him what became of his mustaches. This is the beginning of a beautifully drawn relationship. A scene in which the child is testing Newton's theory of gravity remains in the mind's eye. There are many scenes that are visually appealing, in addition to being clever and spinning the plot along nicely. If this isn't made into a movie, I cannot imagine why. There is so much in this that is tailor made for cinematic treatment.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Impossible. It is much too long, BUT yes I wanted to just keep listening rather than attending to things...

Any additional comments?

Loved it. At the end, I went back and listened to the beginning and found myself thinking, "Ah!!" I really could have listened to the whole thing again! There were so many nuances and there was such depth of detail that revealed itself when I listened again. What a great book!

68 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Conversational Olympics

Man, I was so bored listening to this book. If I had to describe the book in a few words, I'd call it Conversational Olympics. This is not a thriller, suspense, romance, or even a drama. It's a series of anecdotes or vignettes, little stories within one big story, that range from thoughts about what the main character ate at breakfast, to philosophical conversations about society at the time. The performance of the reader was very good, and the writing was a poetry of words. But, there is very little action, and the Count (main character) was fairly bland, although accomplished in the ways an aristocrat might be of the times. I thought some of the other characters had more color, felt more real, than the Count. At least they got angry, expressed themselves emotionally and physically that I could relate to. I kept waiting for something important to happen in the book. But, it just plateaued at the start and kept plateauing throughout. Although this book falls in the category of historical fiction, I'd call it more fiction than historical. Historical events are mentioned here and there, but they are glossed over. I made it to Chapter 23, but just could not finish it.

45 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

The grown-up male version of The Little Princess

When I listened to the preview of this book, I bought it immediately because it made me feel like I felt when I listened to “ A Little Princess.” And lucky for me, it was the grown up male version of that story. It begins with Count Alexander Rostov being led from his suite to his new quarters, a dreary attic, as a result of being under house-arrest for being an unrepentant aristocrat. He accepts his fate with grace and dignity. His life in the Metropol, while narrowly restricted, is never lonely. His friends visit, he meets the guests, and becomes friends with the staff. Life for the count is rich, as the Metropol has a bar, a restaurant, a barber shop, a card room, the piazza, etc. Towles paints the picture of the hotel beautifully. Like Rules of Civility, the book is classy. It does get a bit drawn out in spots, but even there it's more relaxing than annoying. And the narrator? Just perfect!

45 personnes ont trouvé cela utile