Simon Hughes and James Pearce join Tony Evans to unpack a chaotic final act in Nottingham, from VAR confusion and Alexis Mac Allister’s stoppage-time strike to a worrying first-half display that raised familiar concerns. Did the late winner at the City Ground just paper over the cracks?

The panel discuss Florian Wirtz’s late withdrawal, and the impact of Rio Ngumoha off the bench. There’s also no avoiding the Mohamed Salah conversation: a growing goal drought, a smirk when substituted, and a renewed debate over his future and relationship with Arne Slot.

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans

With: Simon Hughes & James Pearce

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Andy Jones and James Pearce join Tony Evans to react to Arne Slot’s latest press conference, assess the ongoing right-back crisis, and dig deeper into the form of Curtis Jones and Milos Kerkez.

Next up Liverpool head to Nottingham Forest with confidence growing — but questions still swirling.

The panel also discuss Liverpool’s excitement — and concern — over teenage talent Josh Abe and debate shock transfer links involving bitter rivals!

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans

With: Andy Jones & James Pearce

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Andy Jones and James Pearce join Tony Evans to break down the 3–0 win at Anfield, asking what the strong line-up tells us about Slot’s priorities and whether the FA Cup now carries extra importance this season.

Then comes the big conversation. Mohamed Salah’s overall numbers are still strong, but his game looks different. The panel dig into his post-AFCON form, his creative output, his relationship with Slot, and where he could be playing football next season if this is to be his last with Liverpool.

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans

With: Andy Jones & James Pearce

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Andy Jones and Simon Hughes join Tony Evans to discuss Liverpool grinding out a crucial 1–0 win at Sunderland, breaking the Black Cats unbeaten home record this season.

The guys analyse Virgil van Dijk’s match-winning goal, a more resilient defensive display, and the growing injury crisis at right-back after Wataru Endo’s setback.

There’s a discussion on Ibrahima Konaté’s form and future. Surely the club can’t allow him to leave for free in the summer?

The panel also tackle Arne Slot’s latest comments on Champions League qualification and a look ahead to Brighton in the FA Cup. Is this an important competition this season?

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans

With: Andy Jones & Simon Hughes

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

James Pearce and Simon Hughes join Tony Evans to dissect the chaotic defeat to Manchester City — from Szoboszlai’s stunning opener to VAR controversy, a red card, and two late City goals.

The panel debate whether Liverpool were hard done by or simply running out of steam, before attention turns to a worrying league table. Is Champions League qualification starting to look unlikely?

There’s also discussion on Caoimhin Kelleher’s candid comments on Diogo Jota, Curtis Jones’ contract situation, Harvey Elliott’s loan dilemma, fresh injury concerns — and whether Liverpool can steady themselves with a crucial run of fixtures ahead. Next up, a daunting trip to the Stadium of Light.

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans

With: Simon Hughes & James Pearce

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

James Pearce and Simon Hughes join Tony Evans to assess what a quiet deadline means for Arne Slot’s squad, including what to expect from summer arrival Jeremy Jacquet and whether Liverpool are taking a risk on depth. Does Liverpool’s January transfer window close with more questions than answers?

The panel dig into Richard Hughes’ recent comments on patient long-term recruitment, debate concerns around centre-back options and squad management, as well as respond to criticism over Slot’s rotation and youth development.

Finally, attention turns to a huge clash with Manchester City at Anfield on Sunday.

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans

With: Simon Hughs & James Pearce

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Simon Hughes and James Pearce join Tony Evans to react to Liverpool’s 4–1 victory over Newcastle, a game transformed by Hugo Ekitike’s two goals in two minutes and an emotional night for Ibrahima Konaté, who capped his return with a goal.

There’s also some deadline day activity to discuss, with Richard Hughes making late moves in the January window, plus the guys discuss Dominik Szoboszlai’s eyebrow raising comments on his Liverpool future.

Finally, with Manchester City coming to Anfield next weekend, are Liverpool finally back — or is caution still required?

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

Host: Tony Evans


With: Simon Hughes & James Pearce


Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Simon Hughes and James Pearce join Tony Evans to break down Wednesday night’s European rout, standout performances and another injury which further leaves Liverpool frighteningly thin at the back

There’s also reaction to Slot’s eyebrow-raising comments about last season’s title and squad depth, and discussion about why the Liverpool hierarchy are sticking by their man.

Finally, attention turns to a huge weekend clash with Newcastle, with Liverpool winless in five league games and looking over their shoulder at the chasing pack of teams just behind them.

Want to get in touch with your thoughts? Email: walkon@theathletic.com

We’re asking you to fill out a quick survey about you and your podcast habits by going to theathletic.com/survey26. Three lucky entries will win $/£100 worth of Amazon vouchers too. So whether you’re a long-time listener or a new one, we want your feedback. Go to: theathletic.com/survey26

Host: Tony Evans

With: Simon Hughs & James Pearce

Producers: Guy Clarke & Nick Thomson

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.