This week, the girls are joined by their dear friend Nathan for a deep dive into everyone’s newest (and hottest) obsession: Heated Rivalry. They talk about getting back to work after the holiday break (derogatory), the surprising pipeline from Christian rock to pop stardom (looking at you, Katy), and the tragic phenomenon of early-aughts icons sliding into full-blown mom drama (hate to see it). They wrap things up with a game of MASH and build Nathan the ultimate sports-romance happily-ever-after!

This week, the girls unwrap a Christmas Spectacular packed with festive chaos and peak December vibes. They dive into two Christmas romances: A Merry Little Ex-Mas, starring Alicia Silverstone (Cher Horowitz, all grown up) and Oliver Hudson (Goldie’s stud-muffin son), before moving on to The Merry Gentlemen with Chad Michael Murray and Britt Robertson—because apparently Christmas movies are required to include at least one millennial crush. They wrap it all up with a holiday edition of the millennial classic MASH to determine their ultimate Christmas movie fates!

This week, the girls dive into Brimstone by Callie Hart. Along the way, Gillian gives an update on her ongoing court case (still somehow not in jail), they unpack the unexpected cultural relevance of Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman, and share thoughts on the new Diddy documentary. They wrap things up with a game, as always, because structure is fake but bits are forever.