The morning after an election that reshaped national politics, Gov. Kelly Armstrong joined Plain Talk for a blunt debrief on a midterm had a couple of surprises, but largely left the status quo in place in North Dakota.
While Democrats swept into comfortable majorities in both the U.S. House and Senate, Armstrong didn't sugarcoat the national drubbing for Republicans nationally.
"People say blue wave, people say tsunami—it was a bloodbath last night," Armstrong said. "There's no other way to describe it. You lose a ton of your thought leaders. You lose your policy leaders, you lose your political minds."
He pointed to economic pain and widespread fatigue with political noise. "Turns out the polls were wrong," he said. The bias, though, was in favor of Republicans in that it understated the breadth of support for Democrats.
"When you control all three branches of government, the midterms aren't particularly great," Armstrong noted. "When you put the president involved in that, you turn the volume up to 11. A lot of Republicans stayed home, and Democrats across the country were very, very motivated to vote."
Yet while states like Texas saw major Democratic shifts, the wave missed North Dakota, where statewide Republicans won by about the same margins they usually do.
We asked Armstron why.
"One, because I don't think North Dakota lives on outrage culture the same way everywhere else does, which is really a great, positive thing," he said. "When you try and tell everybody that the world in North Dakota just absolutely sucks, I don't feel that on the ground."
On ballot measures, Armstrong reflected on the defeat of Measure 1, which he championed to raise the constitutional amendment threshold to 60%. Despite the loss, the governor said he was glad he pursued it.
"The best advice I ever got when I was a starting lawyer was from my law partner's father in Dickinson," Armstrong said. "He said, 'If you're winning every case you're taking to trial, you're not trying enough cases.'"
He also argued the fight over Measure 1 helped sink Measure 2's universal school meals mandate.
"Measure 1 helped Measure 2 go down, so we don't have any constitutionally mandated spending yet, is the way I would put it," Armstrong said. He threw cold water on lawmakers passing it in statute this winter: "The laws of political gravity don't go away...I'd be hard-pressed to see a ton of motivation to move something this session on that."
Armstrong also took aim at far-right legislative candidates backed by the Citizens Alliance who lost on election night.
"I am not particularly upset when Citizens Alliance has a bad night," Armstrong said bluntly, "because I think they're bad for the Republican Party and bad for North Dakota."
For Congresswoman-elect Julie Fedorchak entering a Democratic-controlled House, his advice was pragmatic.
"The math is the math in the House," Armstrong said. "Any bill that the Democrats want to move through in D.C. is going to move. You're trying to get a semicolon changed to a comma in a CR so you can just survive."
And his warning to incoming congressional Democrats? Don't spend the next two years impeaching cabinet members instead of tackling permitting and costs. "Listen to your Democratic governors that are begging for infrastructure reform," Armstrong said. "They need to walk and chew gum at the same time."
After the interview, Chad and I briefly reviewed our election predictions. While we both correctly forecast the defeat of Measures 1 and 2, the sheer scale of the national Democratic wave blew past our expectations.
If you want to participate in Plain Talk, just give us a call or text at 701-587-3141. It's super easy — leave your message, tell us your name and where you're from, and we might feature it on an upcoming episode. To subscribe to Plain Talk, search for the show wherever you get your podcasts or use one of the links below.
Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Pocket Casts | Episode Archive