Send us Fan Mail

The wait is over! Back in January, Maddie and I sat down to watch Wolf Man (2025) for the very first time, and now we're sharing our unfiltered thoughts. Did this modern take on the classic monster live up to the hype? Was the horror, gore, and transformation everything we hoped for? And how does it compare to other werewolf movies?

Join us as we break it all down our favorite moments, the biggest surprises, and whether Wolf Man earns its place in horror history. Watch now, and let us know your thoughts in the comments!

Horror First-Timers:
Podcast: www.buzzsprout.com/2353100
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers

Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS

#firsttimewatching #filmtok #podcast #horrormoviepodcast #moviereview #movie #bodyhorror #universalmonsters #leighwhannell #wolfmanmovie #werewolf #wolfman #monstermovies #creaturefeature #horrorfilmanalysis #filmreactions

Support the show

Send us a text

In this intense sixth episode of "Horror First-Timers," I'm joined by one of my best friends, Bailey Sullivan from Careful Gaze, as we dive headfirst into Darren Aronofsky’s psychological thriller mother! This controversial film takes us on a wild ride through symbolism, chaos, and jaw-dropping moments—and it’s Bailey’s first time experiencing it all!

From the film’s unsettling tension to its shocking twists, we dissect what makes mother! such a polarizing and unforgettable piece of horror. Hear Bailey’s raw reactions, thoughts on the film’s deeper meanings, and whether the chaos won him over.

Don't forget to subscribe for more thrilling episodes as we explore the horror genre's most thought-provoking and terrifying films, one first-time viewing at a time.

@CarefulGaze
www.carefulgaze.com

Horror First-Timers:
Podcast: www.buzzsprout.com/2353100
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers

Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS

#firsttimewatching #filmtok #podcast #horrormoviepodcast #moviereview #movie #mother #darrenaronofsky #psychologicalthriller #horrorfilmanalysis #filmreactions

Support the show

Send us a text

DISCLAIMER: My hard drive did not like me when I went to finally finish editing this video so for the most part this is just an audio friendly podcast with little to no video content.

Welcome back to "Horror First-Timers"! In this thrilling fifth episode, Maddie Franz and I sink our teeth into the 90s werewolf classic, Bad Moon. Join us as Maddie experiences this cult horror film for the very first time, taking in all the fur-raising scares and campy 90s vibes.

Bad Moon brings the werewolf genre to life with a unique twist, and we're here to break down every howl, transformation, and jump scare. From the practical effects to the intense family dynamics, we'll explore what makes this film a hidden gem in the world of horror.

Tune in to hear Maddie's raw reactions, thoughts, and whether this movie has earned a spot in her horror favorites. Don't forget to subscribe to "Horror First-Timers" for more hair-raising episodes as we continue our journey through the most terrifying tales the horror genre has to offer—one film at a time.

Horror First-Timers:
Podcast: www.buzzsprout.com/2353100
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers

Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS

#firsttimewatching #filmtok #podcast #horrormoviepodcast #moviereview #movie #badmoon #werewolf #werewolfmovie #horror

Support the show