In this special Christmas popcorn episode, the guys tackle a topic every Christian parent eventually faces — how to navigate Santa, the Tooth Fairy, the Easter Bunny, and holiday traditions while keeping Jesus at the center. What starts as a quick-hitter turns into a surprisingly thoughtful, funny, and honest discussion about faith, fantasy, and parenting.

The conversation explores the tension between imagination and truth, especially for kids who are learning about Jesus alongside characters like Santa. The hosts share personal stories of when they realized Santa was not real, awkward family moments, schoolyard revelations, and the challenges parents face when well-meaning relatives drop truth bombs at the wrong time.

They wrestle with common Christian objections to holidays — including claims of pagan origins, Halloween concerns, and Old Testament laws — and discuss why selectively applying Scripture often misses the heart of the Gospel. Rather than focusing on rigid rules, the group emphasizes intent, posture, and keeping everything in its proper place.

Practical parenting ideas surface throughout the episode, including framing Santa as fun, clearly distinguishing Jesus as real and central, planting seeds early, and allowing traditions to “age out” naturally. The guys also talk about community outreach events, church-led alternatives to Halloween, and why holidays can actually be powerful opportunities to bring light into dark spaces.

The episode lands on a simple but freeing conclusion: holidays are meant to be joyful. Faith does not require fear. When Jesus is clearly presented as the truth, fantasy does not threaten faith. The group wraps with laughter, self-awareness, and a slightly chaotic Christmas sendoff — staying true to the Simply Heaven style.