What a great story!

I am a huge Rachel Aaron fan and as usual, she checks all the boxes. Beautiful descriptions, interesting characters with different motives and storylines, a villain you didn't expect....allllll that good stuff.

I loved Reliance- she is the most interesting character to me but Mary is a close second. She will be a big player in the next book for sure, a perfect good vs. evil plot device. Josie was interesting enough, she is smart and passionate and adds a good balance.

I personally, am not a huge fan of western stories, only because I find them a bit boring for world-building and it isn't a landscape I would want to vacation to. The story dragged for me at times because they didn't go anywhere besides the caves and town. Despite that, each location had a lot going on and I wasn't bored...just couldn't visualize it as well. Which I firmly believe is my personal tastes and not the fault of the author.

I am also not very familiar with indigenous culture and this made for an enlightening read, my only regret is not seeing Custers demise on the page...I bet it was glorious.

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Great new series

I enjoyed this book. I would've liked for the voices of the characters to be more diverse as it was hard to tell them apart sometimes. I am looking forward to the next book in this series

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Good story

Interesting characters, hero’s and villains.love the premise of the crystal! Hope there will be more than 2 books!

Excellent Weird West / Fantasy Story

Lots to love about this story. It unfolds in a very natural way that's fun to listen to. the worldbuilding is fascinating and the characters are complex enough to be interesting.

it's really wasn't that bad, waiting for the next.

I really wanted to love it, this authors Heartstriker series and the other DFZ books were so good... so, so, SO good I've recommended them to several others but then she did some other project under a nomme de plume that I couldn't get into, so even though this sounded really good I was hesitant... so it IS all over the place at first and hard to follow along and the characters are all kind of annoying-- but the premise behind it is intriguing and it did suck me in. I'll await the next in the series to make up my mind-- which is better than the other book she wrote that i couldn't get past like the second chapter and returned... I'll revisit the DFZ until then...

SIDE NOTE: The narrator wasn't awful. by the end of the book i could differentiate characters, but in the beginning all their voices sounded so similar it made it more confusing... but I've definitely heard worse.

Disappointing

I just did not feel connected to the characters as I have in Aaron’s other books. I will not continue the series.

A Beautiful Twisting Thread

This book is led by three female leads, each distinct in their flaws and strengths, struggling against their world, their circumstances, and sometimes even against each other to try and achieve their goals.

Another Enjoyable Aaron Series

This is an enjoyable urban fantasy set in 1860s in the Dakotas. It very much has a gold rush theme but with gold replaced by a new substance called 'crystal' - a rock with interesting properties (mostly explosive). The story follows the POVs of three women - each uniquely different and with different objectives and goals. Rachel Aaron's strength has always been her quirky characters and those who have enjoyed her other books should really like this series as well. Note: I listened to the audio book and the narrator had a unique voice that felt right for the characters and setting. It was an enjoyable listen.

Story: Three people will meet fate in an outpost fort near Deadwood, South Dakota: Mary (a half Lakota guide to the mining tunnels), Josie (who has come to claim the inheritance of her wealthy but recently deceased mining company owner Uncle), and Rel (who came to the fort to find the murderer of her family). Their paths will cross and each will have their demons and secrets as they must band together and survive the claim of the century.

Each of the main characters has a unique backstory and voice - you will never confuse the characters. Upright Josie, mousy Mary, and vicious Rel each have to survive a fort full of soldiers and men - while also managing to survive in the mines as well. There are several side characters and one male gets a small POV section now and then. But for the most part, we are following the main three and their stories.

There is plenty of action and those who read Aaron know to expect interesting sidekicks and very fun interactions with all kinds of objects. There isn't much 'magic', which I preferred. The story is fairly straightforward mining with a bit of the mystery of the crystal and why it is so desired by the US government and the miners. This first book is about the main characters meeting and then getting to know each other's good and bad parts.

The audio narration was well done. The narrator doesn't do accents well but she had a good sympathetic read for Aaron's style and uniqueness. It was well worth listening to the audio version to really get into the feel of the 1860s and the various characters.

In all, an enjoyable romp as always from Rachel Aaron.

Another Aaron Book at the Top of My Favorites List

Rachel Aaron's Heartstriker series is my #1 favorite series ever; No joke. I've since devoured everything else she has written and when I found she had written another book I knew I would absolutely read it. I was intrigued by the idea of Mary Good Crow although it was hard to really know what I was getting into. Mary Good Crow is a story unlike any ive read before and I absolutely love it. The narrator was a perfect choice here. Rachel has a way of developing characters that makes the reader care deeply about them. One of Rachel's greatest talents in is writing dialogue between the characters that draws the reader into the story. Rachel doesn't simply tell a story and this is what puts her books at the very top of my nearly 600 audio book library. I am anxiously awaiting the next book in the series!