Repeat of

Not word for word at first but the same plot and people. And finally the same words. So if you have bought "An Unpardonable Crime" dont get this.

13 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Engrossing,historical mystery

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. The writing is incredibly vivid and totally enthralling. It is a mystery, with many threads. It is not fast paced, but clues and details are gradually revealed until finally it all comes together at the end.
Much of the pleasure of the listen comes from the historical backdrop for the story. I love the details of life in the early 19th century. The author draws a fabulous picture of society, the social conventions, the dress and acceptable etiquette observed by the affluent through to the extreme poverty, filth and violence endured by the poor. Life in a boys school and the acceptability of thrashing and the apparent inevitability of bullying are also fascinating to hear about.
The narrator is quite wonderful too. He does a great job with portraying the various English, American and Irish accents of the characters and he really added to my enjoyment of the book.
I have to admit that the involvement of the schoolmaster throughout the story is at at times a little contrived but this did not detract from my enjoyment. The child Edgar Allen Poe does appear throughout the story and although he is integral to the tale, any child would have served to play the part just as well. So don't read this just because you are a fan of Poe, that may result in disappointment.
All in all a rich and vivid picture of early 19th century London, with a cleverly woven mystery to keep you guessing.

7 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Highly recommended

An fascinating mystery which keeps the listener engaged from start to finish. Despite the number of characters and storylines, Andrew Taylor successfully ties it all together in a brilliant finale. As usual, the extraordinary Alex Jennings provides narration that makes the listen first rate.

Great, fun story, well narrated

Loved it, the narrator added another dimension in fleshing out the characters. The story had twists and turns, but they never felt gratuitous.