Votre titre Audible gratuit
-
That All Shall Be Saved
- Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation
- Lu par : Derek Perkins
- Durée : 7 h et 3 min
- Catégories : Sciences sociales et politiques, Philosophie

Vous êtes membre Amazon Prime ?
Bénéficiez automatiquement de 2 livres audio offerts.Bonne écoute !
Les auditeurs ayant acheté ce titre ont aussi aimé
-
The Experience of God
- Being, Consciousness, Bliss
- De : David Bentley Hart
- Lu par : Tom Pile
- Durée : 12 h et 13 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Despite the recent ferocious public debate about belief, the concept most central to the discussion "God" frequently remains vaguely and obscurely described. Are those engaged in these arguments even talking about the same thing? In a wide-ranging response to this confusion, esteemed scholar David Bentley Hart pursues a clarification of how the word "God” functions in the world’s great theistic faiths.
-
Alive in God
- A Christian Imagination
- De : Timothy Radcliffe
- Lu par : Steven Crossley
- Durée : 15 h et 20 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
How can Christianity touch the imagination of our contemporaries when ever fewer people in the West identify as religious? Timothy Radcliffe argues we must show how everything we believe is an invitation to live fully. God says, ‘I put before you life and death: choose life’. Anyone who understands the beauty and messiness of human life - novelists, poets, filmmakers and so on - can be our allies, whether they believe or not. The challenge is not today’s secularism but its banality.
-
Let Us Dream
- The Path to a Better Future
- De : Pope Francis
- Lu par : Arthur Morey
- Durée : 4 h et 50 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In the COVID crisis, the beloved shepherd of over one billion Catholics saw the cruelty and inequity of our society exposed more vividly than ever before. He also saw, in the resilience, generosity and creativity of so many people, the means to rescue our society, our economy and our planet. In direct, powerful prose, Pope Francis urges us not to let the pain be in vain. He begins Let Us Dream by exploring what this crisis can teach us about how to handle upheaval of any kind in our own lives and the world at large.
-
The Hebrew Bible
- A Translation with Commentary
- De : Robert Alter
- Lu par : Edoardo Ballerini
- Durée : 64 h et 3 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
A masterpiece of deep learning and fine sensibility, Robert Alter's translation of the Hebrew Bible, now complete, reanimates one of the formative works of our culture. Capturing its brilliantly compact poetry and finely wrought, purposeful prose, Alter renews the Old Testament as a source of literary power and spiritual inspiration. From the family frictions of Genesis and King David's flawed humanity to the serene wisdom of Psalms and Job's incendiary questioning of God's ways, these magnificent works of world literature resonate with a startling immediacy.
-
Dominion
- The Making of the Western Mind
- De : Tom Holland
- Lu par : Mark Meadows, Tom Holland
- Durée : 22 h et 17 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Christianity is the most enduring and influential legacy of the ancient world, and its emergence the single most transformative development in Western history. Even the increasing number in the West today who have abandoned the faith of their forebears, and dismiss all religion as pointless superstition, remain recognisably its heirs. Seen close up, the division between a sceptic and a believer may seem unbridgeable. Widen the focus, though, and Christianity's enduring impact upon the West can be seen in the emergence of much that has traditionally been cast as its nemesis.
-
The Lost Message of Paul
- Has the Church Misunderstood the Apostle Paul?
- De : Steve Chalke
- Lu par : Steve Chalke
- Durée : 8 h et 36 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
We have misunderstood Paul, badly. We have read his words through our own set of assumptions. We need to begin with Paul’s world view, to see things the way he saw them. What if ‘original sin’ was never part of Paul’s thinking? What if the idea that we are saved by faith in Christ, as Luther argued, was based on a mistranslation of Paul’s words and a misunderstanding of Paul’s thinking?
-
The Experience of God
- Being, Consciousness, Bliss
- De : David Bentley Hart
- Lu par : Tom Pile
- Durée : 12 h et 13 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Despite the recent ferocious public debate about belief, the concept most central to the discussion "God" frequently remains vaguely and obscurely described. Are those engaged in these arguments even talking about the same thing? In a wide-ranging response to this confusion, esteemed scholar David Bentley Hart pursues a clarification of how the word "God” functions in the world’s great theistic faiths.
-
Alive in God
- A Christian Imagination
- De : Timothy Radcliffe
- Lu par : Steven Crossley
- Durée : 15 h et 20 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
How can Christianity touch the imagination of our contemporaries when ever fewer people in the West identify as religious? Timothy Radcliffe argues we must show how everything we believe is an invitation to live fully. God says, ‘I put before you life and death: choose life’. Anyone who understands the beauty and messiness of human life - novelists, poets, filmmakers and so on - can be our allies, whether they believe or not. The challenge is not today’s secularism but its banality.
-
Let Us Dream
- The Path to a Better Future
- De : Pope Francis
- Lu par : Arthur Morey
- Durée : 4 h et 50 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In the COVID crisis, the beloved shepherd of over one billion Catholics saw the cruelty and inequity of our society exposed more vividly than ever before. He also saw, in the resilience, generosity and creativity of so many people, the means to rescue our society, our economy and our planet. In direct, powerful prose, Pope Francis urges us not to let the pain be in vain. He begins Let Us Dream by exploring what this crisis can teach us about how to handle upheaval of any kind in our own lives and the world at large.
-
The Hebrew Bible
- A Translation with Commentary
- De : Robert Alter
- Lu par : Edoardo Ballerini
- Durée : 64 h et 3 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
A masterpiece of deep learning and fine sensibility, Robert Alter's translation of the Hebrew Bible, now complete, reanimates one of the formative works of our culture. Capturing its brilliantly compact poetry and finely wrought, purposeful prose, Alter renews the Old Testament as a source of literary power and spiritual inspiration. From the family frictions of Genesis and King David's flawed humanity to the serene wisdom of Psalms and Job's incendiary questioning of God's ways, these magnificent works of world literature resonate with a startling immediacy.
-
Dominion
- The Making of the Western Mind
- De : Tom Holland
- Lu par : Mark Meadows, Tom Holland
- Durée : 22 h et 17 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Christianity is the most enduring and influential legacy of the ancient world, and its emergence the single most transformative development in Western history. Even the increasing number in the West today who have abandoned the faith of their forebears, and dismiss all religion as pointless superstition, remain recognisably its heirs. Seen close up, the division between a sceptic and a believer may seem unbridgeable. Widen the focus, though, and Christianity's enduring impact upon the West can be seen in the emergence of much that has traditionally been cast as its nemesis.
-
The Lost Message of Paul
- Has the Church Misunderstood the Apostle Paul?
- De : Steve Chalke
- Lu par : Steve Chalke
- Durée : 8 h et 36 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
We have misunderstood Paul, badly. We have read his words through our own set of assumptions. We need to begin with Paul’s world view, to see things the way he saw them. What if ‘original sin’ was never part of Paul’s thinking? What if the idea that we are saved by faith in Christ, as Luther argued, was based on a mistranslation of Paul’s words and a misunderstanding of Paul’s thinking?
-
Everything Is Spiritual
- A Brief Guide to Who We Are and What We're Doing Here
- De : Rob Bell
- Lu par : Rob Bell
- Durée : 6 h et 59 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In Everything Is Spiritual, author Rob Bell explores how ideas about creation, love and connection shaped him and how they shape every one of us. Bell observes that more than anything, people want to understand their purpose here on earth. And when you embrace who and where you come from, including your wounds, your pains and your regrets, you will discover that lurking there in the mess of life is an invitation to expand - just as the universe has been expanding for 13 billion years.
-
Thy Will Be Done
- The 2021 Lent Book
- De : Stephen Cherry
- Lu par : Stephen Cherry
- Durée : 4 h et 18 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
At a time of change, uncertainty and widespread anxiety, we need to discover again the freshness of our most familiar spiritual resources. Stephen Cherry’s Lent Book does exactly this by inviting the listener to immerse themselves in the most central, important and iconic of Christian prayers - the Lord’s Prayer, the Our Father.
-
Saying Yes to Life
- The Archibishop of Canterbury's Lent Book 2020
- De : Ruth Valerio
- Lu par : Helen Lloyd
- Durée : 7 h et 29 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Saying Yes to Life lifts our focus from natural, everyday concerns to issues that are having an impact on millions of lives around the world. As people made in the image of God, we are entrusted to look after what he has created: to share in God’s joy and ingenuity in making a difference for good. Ruth Valerio imaginatively draws on the Days of Creation (Genesis 1) as she relates themes of light, water, land, the seasons, other creatures, humankind, Sabbath rest and resurrection hope to matters of environmental, ethical and social concern.
-
A Secret History of Christianity: Jesus, the Last Inkling, and the Evolution of Consciousness
- De : Mark Vernon
- Lu par : Mark Vernon
- Durée : 6 h et 45 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Christianity is in crisis in the West. The Inkling friend of C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien, Owen Barfield, analysed why. He developed an account of our spiritual predicament that is radical and illuminating. Barfield realized that the human experience of life shifts fundamentally over periods of cultural time. Our perception of nature, the cosmos, and the divine changes dramatically across history.
-
Love Matters More
- How Fighting to Be Right Keeps Us from Loving Like Jesus
- De : Jared Byas
- Lu par : Jared Byas
- Durée : 4 h et 51 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
For years, Christians have argued, debated, and fought one another while "speaking the truth in love," yet we are no closer to the grace-filled life Jesus modeled. Biblical scholar and popular podcast host of The Bible for Normal People, Jared Byas casts a new vision for the Christian life that's built not on certainty, but on the risk of love.
-
Jesus Through Middle Eastern Eyes: Cultural Studies in the Gospels
- De : Kenneth E. Bailey
- Lu par : Lloyd James
- Durée : 16 h et 26 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Beginning with Jesus' birth, Ken Bailey leads you on a kaleidoscopic study of Jesus throughout the four Gospels. Bailey examines the life and ministry of Jesus with attention to the Lord's Prayer, the Beatitudes, Jesus' relationship to women, and especially Jesus' parables. Through it all, Bailey employs his trademark expertise as a master of Middle Eastern culture to lead you into a deeper understanding of the person and significance of Jesus within his own cultural context.
-
Following Jesus
- Finding Our Way Home in an Age of Anxiety
- De : Henri J. M. Nouwen, Richard Rohr, Gabrielle Earnshaw
- Lu par : Fred Sanders
- Durée : 3 h et 31 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
At one of the lowest points in Henri Nouwen’s life, he gave a series of lectures on the importance of following Jesus in an age of anxiety. Drawn from those talks, this new work reveals what sustained Nouwen to remain faithful to the teachings of Jesus and led him to become an icon of compassion and vulnerability. Here, he writes eloquently about calling and purpose, fear and hope. And he explains why - with so many choices available to the 21st-century seeker - the greatest reward for those looking for spiritual direction is rediscovering Jesus’ teaching on love.
-
Being Disciples
- Essentials of the Christian Life
- De : Rowan Williams
- Lu par : Peter Noble
- Durée : 2 h et 16 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
This fresh and inspiring look at the meaning of discipleship covers the essentials of the Christian life, including: faith, hope and love; forgiveness; holiness; social action; and life in the Spirit. Written for the general listener by one of our greatest living theologians, this book will help you to see more clearly, love more dearly and follow more nearly the way of Jesus Christ.
-
Time of the Magicians
- The Invention of Modern Thought, 1919-29
- De : Wolfram Eilenberger
- Lu par : Rhett Samuel Price
- Durée : 13 h
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The year is 1919. Walter Benjamin flees his overbearing father to scrape a living as a jobbing critic. Ludwig Wittgenstein signs away his inheritance to teach schoolchildren in a provincial Austrian village, seeking spiritual clarity. Martin Heidegger renounces his faith and aligns his fortunes with the phenomenological school of Edmund Husserl. Ernst Cassirer sketches a new schema of human culture at the back of a cramped Berlin tram. The stage is set for a great intellectual drama, which will unfold over the next decade.
-
A Secular Age
- De : Charles Taylor
- Lu par : Dennis Holland
- Durée : 42 h et 7 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
What does it mean to say that we live in a secular age? Almost everyone would agree that we - in the West, at least - largely do. And clearly the place of religion in our societies has changed profoundly in the last few centuries. In what will be a defining book for our time, Charles Taylor takes up the question of what these changes mean - of what, precisely, happens when a society in which it is virtually impossible not to believe in God becomes one in which faith, even for the staunchest believer, is only one human possibility among others.
-
-
La lecture en français n'est pas super
- Écrit par : LG le 14/02/2019
-
The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry
- How to Stay Emotionally Healthy and Spiritually Alive in the Chaos of the Modern World
- De : John Mark Comer, John Ortberg - foreword
- Lu par : John Mark Comer, Kris Koscheski
- Durée : 5 h et 20 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
"Who am I becoming?" That was the question nagging pastor and author John Mark Comer. Outwardly, he appeared successful. But inwardly, things weren’t pretty. So, he turned to a trusted mentor for guidance and heard these words: "Ruthlessly eliminate hurry from your life. Hurry is the great enemy of the spiritual life." It wasn’t the response he expected, but it was - and continues to be - the answer he needs. Within this audiobook, you’ll find a fascinating road map to staying emotionally healthy and spiritually alive in the chaos of the modern world.
-
Searching for Sunday
- Loving, Leaving, and Finding the Church
- De : Rachel Held Evans
- Lu par : Rachel Held Evans
- Durée : 7 h et 28 min
- Version intégrale
-
Global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Like millions of her millennial peers, Rachel Held Evans didn't want to go to church anymore. The hypocrisy, the politics, the gargantuan building budgets, the scandals - church culture seemed so far removed from Jesus. Yet despite her cynicism and misgivings, something kept drawing her back. And so she set out on a journey to understand the Church and to find her place in it.
Description
A stunning reexamination of one of the essential tenets of Christian belief from one of the most provocative and admired writers on religion today.
The great fourth-century church father Basil of Caesarea once observed that, in his time, most Christians believed that hell was not everlasting, and that all would eventually attain salvation. But today, this view is no longer prevalent within Christian communities.
In this momentous book, David Bentley Hart makes the case that nearly two millennia of dogmatic tradition have misled readers on the crucial matter of universal salvation. On the basis of the earliest Christian writings, theological tradition, scripture, and logic, Hart argues that if God is the good creator of all, he is the savior of all, without fail. And if he is not the savior of all, the Kingdom is only a dream, and creation something considerably worse than a nightmare. But it is not so. There is no such thing as eternal damnation; all will be saved.
With great rhetorical power, wit, and emotional range, Hart offers a new perspective on one of Christianity's most important themes.
Autres livres audio du même :
Ce que les auditeurs disent de That All Shall Be Saved
Commentaires - Veuillez sélectionner les onglets ci-dessous pour changer la provenance des commentaires.
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Mary Benton
- 24/11/2019
The most important part...
For a book on such a weighty topic by an author of such exceptional knowledge and intelligence, this book was in real sense, entertaining. David Bentley Hart's incredible vocabulary and keen wit made what could have been a dry analysis a pleasure to listen to. The reading by Derek Perkins was also exceptional. I felt like I was listening to DBH himself, so fluidly did the words roll off his tongue. That said, I think it should be noted that listening to this book is quite acceptable if all one is seeking is an overall gist of DBH's thoughts on this subject. To really study them, one should have a readable copy (Kindle or hard copy). There is a great deal to reflect on here and to capture all of the references (Biblical and otherwise), one would have to keep pausing the audio to make notes.
I chose the former path - to listen and get the gist. I may still buy a copy to read. I certainly think it would be a worthwhile project but I must consider whether I would truly take the time to go through the entire book again (and again) when I essentially heard what I considered the most important part that I wanted to hear. I had already read some discussion of the book and wanted clarity about the part I considered most essential for accepting the author's premise.
While DBH's reasoning skills are extraordinary and quite persuasive, the part I needed to hear had to do with his opinion regarding the proper translation of the Greek term in the Bible that is typically handed on to us as "eternal". All of the reasoning in the world would, for me, have a tough time standing up to the possibility that it conflicted with what Jesus said. DBH indicated that he would have to abandon Christianity if it could be proved to him that the existence of an eternal hell was essential to the faith. I don't know that I could say the same thing. No matter how smart DBH is - or how smart I think I am (no comparison though, to be honest) - the God's Wisdom and Truth is greater. If I otherwise wholly believe in Christ and Christianity, I have to trust that what doesn't make sense to me can still be true and consistent with God as good and loving, even if completely mysterious to me.
I found myself reacting a bit to DBH's mocking tone about believing impossible things. Though DBH presents himself as a believer, it made me wonder if he was going to later produce books trying to convince me that there was no Virgin birth or that Christ did not really rise from the dead. Are these not "impossible things" to our human understanding? Yet I believe them - and I think for good reason - even though my mind cannot fathom them as truly "possible". Granted, I do not have the same "good reason" for believing in an eternal hell but neither am I going to toss out a Church teaching that seems to be supported by Scripture merely because human reason says it doesn't make sense.
I got what I came for. DBH produced - quite far into the book - a thorough enough discussion of the translations of the Greek to convince me that what has been translated as "eternal" is not and should not be unequivocally accepted as a proper translation. The Greek word may or may not mean a very long time but that is quite different from eternal. He also provided additional support to his argument by noting that some prominent Fathers of the early Church assumed that salvation was ultimately universal.
There is much else in this title that is worth pondering, e.g. punishment of the wicked as retributive vs. remedial, consideration of what the freedom in "free will" means, etc. It is definitely worth a read/listen by anyone with even the slightest interest in the subject.
10 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Ropebender
- 07/01/2020
A hard book to listen to, and a hard one to ignore
Because of the deep nature of the theological material in this book, I think a print version is a better choice. The 30 second rewind is too much, and to give adequate study takes too much thought, too many pauses, and no way to fully absorb these controversial ideas.
Most Christians today would jump to quickly dismiss the book as claptrap. That is, unless they take the time to fully digest the logic presented. I personally thought I would immediately see through the anti-biblical beliefs of Mr Hart. Instead, I find myself wanting to discuss this with a few others. It's not easy to get past the overall logical points he makes.
There are some very angry reviews out there for this book. I fear most of them were written by people who never really tried to read the book with an open mind. It's really hard to do that when you have spent many years believing in an eternal hell for evil people.
Carefully read, Heart may shake those long-held views. But I recommend a print version of the book, so you can make marginal notes and use a big black marker over parts you don't agree with.
4 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Timothy K
- 08/11/2019
Wind bag
Mr. Hart works hard to make his point, but all too often he tries to impress his readers with his command of the language. This leads to many passages with needlessly complicated words and phrases.
4 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Marc C.
- 28/12/2019
Thought-provoking with excellent narration
I greatly enjoyed listening to this book, and I plan to listen to it a second time. David Bentley Hart is not an easy author to read, and his vocabulary and erudition can make a book difficult to work through. I was very impressed with the narration here by Derek Perkins. He reads expressively, even with the most challenging vocabulary and detailed philosophical arguments.
Hart's argument in this book is compelling and addresses all of the key arguments that Christian theologians have put forward for an eternal hell over the centuries. He liberally appeals to the reader's (or listener's) instinctive sense of justice and morality throughout the book, but he backs up his frequent emotional appeals with cogent, well-argued philosophical and theological reflections. At the very least, his exposition of the views of some early Christian authors and the meaning of key Greek words in the New Testament opened a new vista for me about the core Christian message. What is salvation really all about, and what does it mean for individuals and all of humanity? The way he develops this point is deeply influential for me, and it will take a while to plumb the depths of meaning therein. I highly recommend this book, and the recording is excellent.
3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Ed B
- 07/10/2019
Best Philosophical Case for Christian Universalism
Going back to the earliest sources of Christianity the author makes the best case for Christian universalism grounded in philosophy I have seen and I have read many a Christn universalist book. The dismissive air toward infernalist arguments is both succinct and charming.
3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Amazon Customer
- 10/12/2019
Can one Defeat God?
Hart is able to reveal a logical treatise that will leave the reader asking one’s self, “why did I ever believe in Eternal Conscience Torment?” To believe in ECT Hell is to believe in a god who can be defeated.... nicely done Hart!
2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Amazon Customer
- 10/12/2019
The Book Is a Masterpiece, the Reader Is the Best
Thomas Talbott once wrote, "If one is looking for an explanation of why so many within the evangelical community, even among the more elite scholars, are woefully ignorant of how universalist interpret the New Testament and put theological ideas together, one need only consider how few of them have ever encountered a vigorous and sustained defense of the doctrine of universal reconciliation. Hart gives that vigorous and sustained defense and more to anyone willing to withhold judgment until having heard both sides of this important matter.
2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- SGMMurray
- 05/11/2020
Best book I’ve read on Christian theology
DBH convinced me of what most atheists know intuitively: that God can’t be the good, omnipotent, eternal tormentor of rational souls.
He helped me understand what the New Atheists miss: that free will implies not autonomy to choose between equal alternatives but rather freedom from choice itself - willing effortlessly and without distraction to draw near to the Good, in accordance with one’s true nature.
He also explains the true meaning of Omnipotence. God is all power - the motive force behind that makes action possible, and the good that motivates every desire. It is impossible for a soul, insofar as it is rational, to desire anything but the good; therefore when a deranged person seeks through an evil action a limited good (the temporary pleasure of vengeance, for instance), it is motivated by the innate rational desire, however distorted through the prism of fallen consciousness, for the Good as such. God is both pokes of the magnet: both the beginning and end of all desire.
Beautifully read, too. Between DBH’s complex ideas, expansive vocabulary, and enviable diction, and the lilting English accent of the reader, this is an excellent sleep aid.
1 personne a trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Elizabeth Weddington
- 09/07/2020
Impeccably argued!
I really enjoyed this from a logical standpoint. extremely well articulated and has put words to feelings I have had for some time, as well as fleshed out unexplored territory of the logical fallacy of eternal conscious torment. See this as a helpful tool used with Jersak's works, which tend to be very pastoral, whereas this is very academic.
1 personne a trouvé cela utile
-
Global
-
Interprétation
-
Histoire

- Free Thinker
- 12/01/2020
An antidote for an infernal problem
The problem of reconciling an eternal hell with a God of infinite goodness has perplexed both theologians and everyday believers for almost two millennia. One would need a calculator to compute the number of books, tracts, and sermons devoted to this very topic.
Dr. Hart takes a different approach than most of his colleagues. According to him, the dilemma is itself an illusion, because there is no eternal place of torment to rationalize away. Those who believe otherwise are either deluded or evil.
This is not exactly a new position, as Dr. Hart is careful to point out in the text. Universalism, or the belief that all human beings will eventually make their peace with God, was taught and faithfully believed during the first five centuries of the Christian era.
According to Dr. Hart, the church began to lose its way beginning with Augustine, who in his masterpiece The City of God describes human history as a tension between two unalterably opposed forces: the kingdom of Christ and the domain of the Devil.
According to Augustine, these two empires are destined to do battle until the end of time, at which point God will consign the evil ones to eternal conscious torment and welcome his blessed ones into his presence forever.
Dr. Hart shouts a hearty "amen" to most of Augustine's thesis, except for the part about evildoers suffering eternal conscious torment. This, he says, is logically and morally incomprehensible. By all means, those who commit horrific evil should pay for their atrocities. But not forever. This is utterly unjustified, even for people as vile as Hitler or Stalin.
So what will ultimately happen to those who spend their mortal lives inflicting pain on others? Dr. Hart says that they will get what they have coming, in the torments of Hell. But, unlike the traditional view, in Hart's model Hell is akin to the traditional Roman Catholic concept of Purgatory, a place of purging where the punishments are designed not so much for retributive as for redemptive purposes.
Simply put, some of us, maybe all of us, will have to go through Hell to get to Heaven.
Dr. Hart builds a strong case for this view. In the process, he deconstructs the numerous assumptions that underlie the traditional view of Hell. He explores the nature of personhood, the concept of freedom, and the role of Christ in redeeming humanity.
I want to keep this review brief, so I shan't elaborate on Dr. Hart's arguments. Instead I will focus on how his critics have responded to the book. I have noticed three typical "rebuttals" of his position, which are as follows:
1. The free will defense: This view says that God honors the freely made choices of his creatures, even when those decisions lead to eternal suffering.
This view is shaky on its surface and disintegrates upon closer examination. After all, no sane earthly parent would let his child run into a burning building simply because she wanted to. He might allow her to suffer a blister on her finger, just to show her why it's a bad idea. But "honor" her irrational choice to destroy herself? Only a lunatic or a sadist would follow that fallacious logic.
2. The argument from church history: This essentially says the Universalism must be false because of the church's long history of proselytizing. Why devote so much effort to spreading the Good News if eventually everyone will end up in the same place?
This argument rests upon the assumption that the only value that Christianity offers is its "get out of Hell free" pass. Since the assumption is false, so is the argument.
3. "Dr. Hart is smug and self-congratulatory; plus, he's a Socialist. So he must be wrong:" This is nothing but the old ad hominem argument, which has been repeated ad nauseum since the days of Aristotle. I won't bother refuting it since it doesn't deserve the effort. Suffice it to say that even a pretentious jerk can be right on occasion.
In other words, Dr. Hart's detractors, so far as I can tell, rely on straw man fallacies, appeals to consequences, or ad hominem attacks, all of which tells me that they have no answer to his arguments.
The question is 'why." Why would people who profess their love for all humanity be so resistant, so unalterably hostile, to the idea of Universalism?
Dr. Hart speculates that their true motivation is the desire for a "positional good."
In other words, it's no fun going to Heaven unless everyone you hate is going to Hell.
As someone who has spent his entire life around "Christians," I have no doubt whatsoever that Dr. Hart is correct in his appraisal. There are no more hateful, spiteful, or malicious people on earth than those tender-hearted followers of the gentle Savior who gave his life for humanity.
As proof, I refer you to any or all of the online message boards populated by people of faith. If there is a Devil, then he speaks through the mouths and keyboards of his most vociferous opponents.
Sadly, I must include Dr. Hart himself in their company. He is every bit as smug and self-congratulatory as the infernalists whom he takes to task in this otherwise excellent book.
In the name of combating pride and puritanism, he reveals himself over and over to be a proud puritan.
This is evident in the many personal attacks he launches throughout the text. Other reviewers have pointed to specific quotes of this nature in the book, so I won’t duplicate their efforts here.
However, I would say that Dr. Hart should spend a little less time pointing fingers and a lot more time looking in the mirror.
Other than this single, regrettable defect, I have nothing but praise for this book. It offers a much-needed remedy to a reproachable illness. I only wish that the good doctor would avail himself of the prescription he offers so heartily to others.
1 personne a trouvé cela utile
Les Top 10
Nous avons sélectionné pour vous la crème du livre audio. Découvrez les meilleurs titres parmi les principales catégories de notre catalogue.
Prix littéraires
Découvrez les lauréats du Prix Goncourt, Prix Renaudot ou encore du Grand Prix du livre audio La Plume de Paon.



Environnement
Bâtissons le monde de demain et découvrez les défis en matière d'environnement, de transition écologique et de développement durable.