Blood Defense

Middling Legal Drama by Famous Prosecutor

Workable and workmanlike legal drama by Marcia Clark, the lead prosecutor in the O.J. Simpson case who retired from law immediately after that famous trial and became a writer.

After writing a series of books featuring a prosecutor, Clark turns in this first entry of a new series to the defense. Samantha Brinkman is an interesting character whose past emerges as she defends a cop accused of killing a famous young starlet and her roommate, along with a few other cases along the way.

While the story itself is probably no more and no less than a decent episode in a TV series, maybe worth a feature length film, it does not carry enough weight as a courtroom drama or as a thriller. The ultimate resolution of the murder case is particularly disappointing (though the set-up for follow-up entries is rather good).

Worse than anything else is the narration. Tavia Gilbert has read a lot of YA, and whatever weight you might expect from Brinkman's character is lost because she sounds like a teen sleuth, like Nancy Drew. That's not altogether terrible -- until she gets to action sequences, where she goes completely over the top and becomes simply unbearable to listen to.

I'm of the opinion that narrators rarely ruin good books, that it's usually in the writing. And no narrator was going to make this story more than an average legal thriller. But Gilbert's performance most definitely detracts from the best aspect of Clark's writing, the character of Sam Brinkman.

The forthcoming second entry to this series does not yet list a narrator. Thanks to the final chapter set-up, I will likely give it a go -- unless Gilbert is the reader, in which case I will NOT listen to it.

26 sur 28 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

I can't listen to this narrator

I can't get past the narrator's voice to listen to this book. I originally ordered the book on Amazon for my Kindle and couldn't get into it so thought I would listen to it while I'm driving. I can't get past the narrator's voice to get into the book so I'm giving up and I'm only a quarter through.

29 sur 32 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Narration turned me off.

Would you try another book from Marcia Clark and/or Tavia Gilbert?

I have read all the Marcia Clark and enjoyed them very much. Two hors into this book I quit listening to it. The story is intriguing but the narration was overly energetic and fast for me to listen to for the whole book. Will have to read it on vacation sometime

31 sur 35 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Relies on an unbelievable sequence of events

Any additional comments?

I was interested in Blood Defense because of Marcia Clark's experience in the courtroom, and I assumed that would come through in the novel.

Unfortunately, the plot relies on an unbelievable sequence of events. Early on the protagonist Samantha Brinkman, a struggling defense attorney, has an extremely contrived encounter with a young delinquent who is also a client. I found myself shouting "no, no, no, this is not believable." From then on, everything that can go wrong does go wrong, and soon the "unexpected" bad turn of events becomes tediously expected. As well, there are incidents that would surely bring the police running in the real world, but in order to sustain the plot Clark acts as if they don't exist or are incompetent. The denouement is silly, and the final chapter is even sillier.

The reading level of the book is basic, and makes too much use of current vernacular. I don't know how many times the phrase "I shot her a dagger" appeared - too many. There little character development.

It isn't all bad, There are snippets of courtroom appearances, and the unfolding mystery held my attention through a little more than half the book in spite of its other defects. Clark clearly has real-world experience with the media, and some of Samantha's media interactions and observations are telling.

The narration is mediocre. Tavia Gilbert has a fine voice but her reading sounds perpetually ironic, and she has a tendency to stress the wrong word in a sentence.

Too bad - one hoped for better. I have not entirely given up on Clark or Gilbert, but I will read the reviews carefully before trying another one.

21 sur 24 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Started off slow

This started off slow not sure it was the story or the narrator. But as the story advanced I did get into it.

4 sur 4 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

I really wanted to like it.

Narrator extremely annoying. Premise was good, could not get past chapter 4. Will request refund.

14 sur 17 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Not impressed

Did not love this book. Marcia Claek's writing is a little amateurish. Characters kind of thinly drawn and the story far fetched.

10 sur 12 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Riveting

Back in 2009 a friend of mine loaned me a book “Without a Doubt” by Marcia Clark. It was about the O. J. trial for which Clark was the head prosecutor. I was impressed by her writing skills. When she wrote the Rachel Knight series I read each of the books. I felt as a former prosecutor she was writing about what she knows best as Knight was a prosecutor. Now Clark has stepped out of her comfort zone writing about a defense attorney. The new series features Samantha Brinkman a criminal defense attorney. Clark has Samantha doing the legal expert bit on local T. V. shows just as Clark herself did. The plot begins with the murder of two women, a T. V. star Chloe Monahan and model Paige Avner. The police eventually arrest a local LAPD detective who was Chloe’s boyfriend.

The book is well written, the pace is fast with lots of suspense as the plot twists and turns. There is some action toward the end of the book. As with the other Clark books there is humor. All of Clark’s principal characters are strong, intelligent women with a sarcastic wit. Clark writes a very realistic story that seems right out of today’s headlines. I am looking forward to the next book in the series. Tavia Gilbert does a good job narrating the story.

15 sur 19 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

Dreadful narration

I cannot honestly review the book, since the narration was so completely horrible I couldn't listen to it. Every blessed sentence was breathlessly read as high drama and in a slightly whiny tone.

I gave the story 3 stars because it required me to enter something.

Returning it.

2 sur 2 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.

standard mystery

This novel was a standard mystery, with a defense attorney putting the clues together. I am not a fan of formulaic mysteries like this, and so I only found it okay. I had expected a level of authenticity, given that the author is a prosecuting attorney of a high profile trial. Not so. She must have based this on fiction she has read rather than her personal experience. Too bad. It did keep me interested enough to finish, but there were some totally unrealistic moments. The protagonist often carries a gun, but she happened not to when investigating a remote and suspicious home. And when her life is in danger, she screams to get attention, but does not think of calling police on her cell phone. The characters don't feel real, but they had some personality. The reader seemed a little too whiny for an attorney, but she did voices very well and is probably perfect for other characters.There were just enough twists and turns to keep me listening.

2 sur 2 personne(s) ont trouvé cet avis utile.