Episodes

  • The Mystery of the Villisca Axe Murderer
    17 Nov 2026

    It's Sunday night, June 9th, 1912, in Villisca, Iowa, a railroad town of about two thousand people where most folks don't bother locking the door. Nearly the whole town is packed into the Presbyterian church for Children's Day, and the woman making sure every kid hits their mark is Sarah Moore. Afterward she walks home with her husband Joe, their four children and two very excited little guests, Lena and Ina Stillinger, who've been invited to sleep over. By 10 o'clock they're all inside the white frame house on East Second Street, and the lamps go down. The next morning the house is quiet in the wrong way. The horses in the barn haven't been fed. The front door is locked. And from the inside, somebody has hung clothing over the windows so nobody can see in. Behind that door are details nobody has ever explained, and a hunt that would run for years after the one person in that house who should not have been there.


    If this case has a hold on you, please follow the show and leave a rating.

    Got a case you want me to dig into, or something unlikely that happened to you? Send it my way at https://unlikelycases.com or drop it in the comments.

    Every source and picture credit for this episode is listed below.


    Sources and picture credits: https://unlikelycases.com/cases/uc-0005-villisca-axe-murders.html


    www.unlikelycases.com

    Show more Show less
    30 min
  • The 1962 Alcatraz Escape: Three Men Lost on a Raincoat Raft
    15 Nov 2026

    June 12th, 1962. It is the morning count on Alcatraz, and in Cell Block B one man will not wake up. The guard raps on the bars, then steps inside and reaches down to shake him, and the head comes off in his hand: painted skin, painted lips, real human hair swept off the prison barbershop floor. Two more cells, two more dummies. Frank Morris and the brothers John and Clarence Anglin have gone through the walls of the most escape-proof prison in America with spoons, forks and a vacuum cleaner motor. Up under the roof they left a secret workshop, where they built a raft out of more than 50 raincoats. Now they have about an eight-hour head start and nothing ahead of them but the cold, fast water of San Francisco Bay. So how did three bank robbers pull it off, and where were they headed?


    Before we follow the manhunt, if this story has you hooked, please follow the show and leave a rating. It really helps these cases reach more listeners.

    Got a case for me, or did something unlikely ever happen to you? Tell me at https://unlikelycases.com or in the comments.

    Every source and picture credit for this episode is listed below.


    Sources and picture credits: https://unlikelycases.com/cases/uc-0004-1962-alcatraz-escape.html


    www.unlikelycases.com

    Show more Show less
    35 min
  • The Night D.B. Cooper Vanished Into the Storm
    10 Nov 2026

    Portland, the afternoon before Thanksgiving, 1971. A calm man in a dark suit and a black tie pays cash for a one-way ticket to Seattle under the name Dan Cooper, orders a bourbon and soda, and lights a cigarette. Soon after takeoff he passes a folded note to a flight attendant, who slips it into her pocket unread. The thirty-six passengers are told only about a minor delay. On the ground, bank staff copy down the serial number of every one of ten thousand twenty-dollar bills. And in the tail of the Boeing 727 sits a set of stairs that airlines built for convenience, never for leaving a plane at ten thousand feet.


    The sources and picture credits for this episode are listed below, if you want to read the public files yourself.

    If you're enjoying Unlikely Cases, follow the show and leave a rating wherever you're listening.


    Sources and picture credits: https://unlikelycases.com/cases/uc-0003-db-cooper.html


    www.unlikelycases.com

    Show more Show less
    15 min
  • The Enduring Mystery of the Roswell Flying Disc
    9 Nov 2026

    Saturday, June 14, 1947. A New Mexico rancher and his 8-year-old son ride past a wide spread of bright scraps in a pasture: rubber, tinfoil, tough paper and thin sticks, all glittering in the sun. The rancher is in a hurry. His boy wants to stop. "Not now," he says, and they ride on. Three weeks later, that same bundle of junk has a sheriff on the phone, an Army air base making an announcement at noon, and a neighbor swearing she saw a piece that would not cut and would not burn. Some of the pieces carried purplish markings no one could read. What was really lying in that pasture?


    If you're enjoying Unlikely Cases, follow the show and leave a rating wherever you're listening.

    Know a case we should cover, or has something unlikely ever happened to you? Tell us at https://unlikelycases.com or in the comments.

    The sources and picture credits are listed below if you want to dig in yourself.


    Sources and picture credits: https://unlikelycases.com/cases/uc-0002-roswell.html


    www.unlikelycases.com

    Show more Show less
    20 min