WHAT REALLY HAPPENED TO HULK HOGAN'S EYE?!

We thought we had already gone down the rabbit hole.

Then YOU guys started commenting.

After hundreds of comments, fan theories and some serious digging, Timbo Slice and Big Poppa Bump revisit the biggest question:

Did Hulk Hogan REALLY get that black eye from a 70 MPH jet ski accident… or did Macho Man Randy Savage actually punch him?

After hearing your theories and reading through the comments from the first episode, the guys revisit the mystery from every angle — the infamous jet ski accident, the Macho Man Randy Savage punch theory, Hogan's own accounts, the medical-clearance story, WrestleMania IX, and the possibility of a much bigger plan involving Hogan and Savage.

But that's only the beginning.

After the Hogan discussion, Big Poppa Bump introduces another strange wrestling rumor from the 1990s:

Did Rey Mysterio Jr. really have a relationship with Jennifer Aniston?

We dig into the National Enquirer story, WCW references, Rey's early career, Spring Stampede 1997 and the strange circumstances surrounding one of the most random wrestling rumors we've ever encountered.

Plus, we crack open another pack of WWE Topps Chrome and talk wrestling collectibles, nostalgia and some of the unforgettable characters of the 80s, 90s and beyond.

As always, we're bringing the questions — and we're counting on you to help us find the answers.

If you remember these stories, have an old magazine, newspaper clipping, recording or firsthand memory, drop it in the comments or reach out to The Stiff Shot Podcast.

Subscribe, follow and join us for more hard-hitting wrestling talk.

#WWE #HulkHogan #RandySavage #MachoMan #WrestleMania9 #ReyMysterio #WCW #WWF #ProWrestling #WrestlingHistory #OldSchoolWrestling #WWEUrbanLegends #TheStiffShotPodcast

Welcome to Episode 7 of The Stiff Shot Podcast! We are bringing out a double-header tonight with a heavy dose of childhood nostalgia and unhinged wrestling history.

First, Timbo Slice and Scott jump into an epic tag-team "Show and Tell" segment. Timbo breaks down his local Target shopping runs to grab modern Mattel re-releases of the iconic 1980s solid-rubber LJN Wrestling Superstars line, detailing the history of rare Canadian "black cards" and unpunched peg holes. Then, Scott reveals his exclusive card packs and rare autographed chase pulls brought directly home from the Topps exhibit booth at WrestleMania Access.

In the second half, the guys crack open the dirt sheets for a deep dive into wrestling conspiracy theories! We analyze the legendary mystery surrounding Hulk Hogan's grotesque black eye at WrestleMania 9. Did the Hulkster really suffer an orbital fracture from a 70 MPH jet ski accident, or did a furious Macho Man Randy Savage cold-cock him over Miss Elizabeth days before the pay-per-view? From Scott Steiner's eyewitness accounts to Vince McMahon's backstage rage and the cancelled SummerSlam 93 booking plans, we leave no stone unturned!

Hit that subscribe button, leave a 5-star review, and join us on the flip side!

📊 Timestamps & Segment Breakdown

• 00:00 - Intro & The "Show and Tell" Extravaganza
• 00:07 - Target Toy Hunting: Modern Mattel LJN Re-Releases
• 01:23 - The History of LJN Canadian "Black Cards" & Grading Metrics Timbo outlines the late-80s history of original Canadian-exclusive Series 6 LJN cards
• 06:23 - The Ultimate Warrior Blue Card Reissue Pull Blue-carded Ultimate Warrior reveal
• 10:43 - The Pre-Order Variant Myth & eBay Gray Market Scalping
• 14:11 - The Dangerous Real-World History of the 1980s LJN Ring Post Recall
• 15:53 - Deep Dive: Hulk Hogan’s Infamous WrestleMania 9 Black Eye Conspiracy The main event of the podcast kicks off as the guys investigate the gnarly orbital bone damage Hogan brought to WrestleMania IX in 1993.
• 16:27 - The Official Story: The 70 MPH Jet Ski Mishap
• 16:47 - The Shoot Theory: Macho Man Randy Savage Sucker Punch Unpacking the backstage rumor mill.
• 18:22 - Coding Commentary & Vince McMahon’s Backstage Backlash Savage's hidden jabs on commentary during the WrestleMania 9 broadcast and look at Vince McMahon’s reported fury over his top babyface ruining months of promo packaging.
• 22:22 - The Backstage Witnesses: Scott Steiner & Jimmy Cornette Scott Steiner’s firsthand testimony inside the Peacock WrestleMania IX documentary.
• 23:56 - The SummerSlam 93 Blueprint & Alternative Booking Realities Scott breaks down an advanced booking theory
• 28:50 - Previewing Conspiracies Part 2 & Channel Wrap-Up Upcoming deep dives for next week—including Johnny Ace, Shawn Michaels faking his 90s back injury, and Green Shirt Guy

📱 Follow The Stiff Shot Podcast On Socials:

• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thestiffshotpod/
• TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thestiffshotpod
• X (Twitter): https://x.com/TheStiffShotPod

⏱️ Chapters

0:00 – WrestleCon pickups & Bob Backlund promo story

4:30 – The bizarre “Gym in a Box” training system explained

10:15 – INSANE Bob Backlund fitness stats (you won’t believe this)

16:40 – PMA philosophy & “Never Capitulate” meaning

22:30 – Health update & legacy of Bob Backlund 27:45 – Iron Sheik meet-and-greet story (all-time classic 😂)

34:10 – Breaking down Iron Sheik’s legendary shoot interviews

40:20 – Wrestling nostalgia: WWF era connections & storytelling

45:00 – Teasing future episodes (Iron Sheik roast & more!)

What happens when you mix old-school wrestling legends, insane shoot stories, and completely unfiltered fan memories? You get one of the most entertaining episodes we’ve ever recorded. In this episode, we dive deep into the wild world of Bob Backlund — from his bizarre “Gym in a Box” training system to unforgettable autograph encounters and the legendary PMA (Positive Mental Attitude) mindset that defined his career. But that’s just the beginning… We also spiral into hilarious and unforgettable stories involving Iron Sheik, including real-life meet-and-greet chaos, iconic shoot interview moments, and why he might be one of the most quotable figures in wrestling history. And yes… we even connect it all to Brock Lesnar’s UFC debut and some of the most random (yet amazing) wrestling memories you’ll ever hear.

👉 If you love: Classic WWF/WWE stories Behind-the-scenes wrestling culture Convention & autograph stories Shoot interviews and unfiltered legends This episode is an absolute MUST WATCH.

💥 Why You NEED to Watch This Episode The truth behind Bob Backlund’s insane real-life workout routines (800+ ab rollouts 😳)

The hilarious reality of meeting wrestling legends in person Deep cuts only real fans will understand (WrestleCon, promos, shoot interviews) The most quotable Iron Sheik moments that still live rent-free today Nostalgia-packed stories that connect multiple wrestling eras together

📢 Follow & Support the Show