Send us Fan Mail

Over the last twelve months, the sentence Jeff hears most from business owners is "AI killed our search traffic." Here's a second sentence from the same twelve months: Google's paid clicks grew 13%, and Google search advertising brought in $63 billion in one quarter. One of those sentences is the headline. The other is the explanation — and most companies have them backward.

In this episode, Jeff slows down the monthly review where "AI did it" shows up on a slide and nobody checks. A new three-year analysis of roughly 10,000 websites shows organic losses are concentrated in publishers and large sites; the typical small business site was roughly flat. Meanwhile, Google moved the goalposts: a sticky "Sponsored results" header, ad blocks roughly doubled in size, the first organic result below the fold, and aggressive algorithm updates. And the suspect everyone names — AI referral traffic — is about one visit in 200.

Three suspects. Two of them can be answered. The one you can't do much about is exactly why it's the convenient one to name.

Send us Fan Mail

This fall, the internet's most trusted reference sites lost Google visibility at the same time. Wikipedia hit its lowest reading since June. Every dictionary in a 2,600-company index fell in the same five weeks. Meanwhile, video, reviews, listings, and discussions gained — YouTube alone added more than the next four gainers combined.

Authority didn’t save the dictionary. What separates the winners from the losers is whether a sentence can replace you. An AI Overview absorbs a definition, and the click never happens. A customer story, a video, a review — the AI can only point at those, and the click survives.

In this episode, Jeff explains why being the answer is now the way to lose if the answer isn’t yours to give, shares how a Portland periodontist built a hundred things no AI could absorb, and gives CEOs a one-hour audit to sort their site into definition and evidence.

Plus: Why Google’s longest spam update in years didn’t move the index at all.

Send us Fan Mail

In 1975, Sylvester Stallone was broke, and a studio kept raising its offer for the Rocky script — reportedly approaching $350,000 — on one condition: a bankable star plays the lead. He said no every time, until they let him play the part himself on a budget of about $1 million.

Most people stop the story there. Jeff doesn't. The price of keeping the role was the budget: no crew, no permits, no safety net, and the famous museum steps run shot at dawn on a prototype rig because they couldn't afford to close a street. The constraint became the movie.

Every business owner has a version of that table — a buyer, a partner, a big client, a term sheet with one line that sounds like a detail. This episode is about what conviction actually costs, why you can't keep control and comfort at the same time, and how to know in advance which part of your business is the role and which part is just the script.

Jeff also tells his own version: the clients he's let go, kindly, because they needed to lead.