On the night of April 11, 1981, something unimaginable happened inside Cabin 28 at the Keddie Resort in Northern California.

By the following morning, three people were dead: 36-year-old Glenna “Sue” Sharp, her 15-year-old son John, and John’s 17-year-old friend, Dana Wingate. Twelve-year-old Tina Sharp was missing. Three young boys who had also been inside the cabin survived.

What happened inside Cabin 28? Who was responsible? And why did Tina disappear that night?

Three years later, Tina’s remains were discovered near Feather Falls, California, but the answers investigators and the Sharp family needed never came.

More than four decades later, the Keddie Cabin Murders remain unsolved. Evidence has resurfaced, investigative theories have evolved, and questions about the original investigation continue to draw attention. Yet no one has been brought to trial for the murders.

In this episode of Nothing Ever Happens Here, we revisit the events surrounding Cabin 28, examine the known timeline and investigative developments, and explore the questions that continue to surround one of California’s most haunting unsolved cases.

Behind the headlines are four people whose lives were taken or forever changed: Sue, John, Dana, and Tina. Their stories deserve more than speculation. They deserve to be remembered, and their case deserves answers.

Because some stories don't end when the headlines fade.

On October 3, 2026, sixteen-year-old Persephone Anjanette Berger lost her life after being struck by a St. Francois County sheriff’s deputy’s patrol vehicle in rural Missouri.

In this episode of Nothing Ever Happens Here, we remember Persephone beyond the headlines and examine the questions surrounding the circumstances of her death. We discuss the sheriff’s public statement, the concerns her family has raised about how they were notified of the deputy’s involvement, and the broader questions of investigative independence and public transparency.

Content note: This episode discusses the death of a minor, a fatal vehicle collision, grief, and an ongoing search for answers.

First Alert 4: 911 Audio

Justice For Persephone Facebook Page

In July 1991, 11-year-old Charles “Arlin” Henderson rode his bicycle away from his home in Moscow Mills, Missouri, expecting to return for dinner. He never came home. More than 35 years later, his disappearance remains unsolved. From a bicycle recovered months later to a false confession that sent investigators down the wrong path, this episode examines the search for answers, a mother’s unwavering hope, and the questions that remain in Arlin’s case. What happened to Arlin Henderson, and could someone still hold the key to finding the truth?

We're back after a hiatus to just have a conversation about the cases we've covered, asking questions, and using comparisons to try and determine why cases, and the attention and coverage they receive, are so different.

Welcome to The Debrief.

If you've listened to the main episode, you already know there are very few publicly available details in Megan Latham's disappearance. And when that's the case, it can be tempting to start filling in the blanks.

Someone knows what happened to Megan.

The question is... will they ever come forward?

I break down a theory of the case and am a little more candid about my feelings regarding Allie’s case and Andrew Hummel.

Most people think danger comes from dark alleys, abandoned buildings, or strangers in the night. But sometimes, the most unsettling mysteries begin inside the place that's supposed to be the safest—their home. What really happened inside that home in New London?

Special thanks to Kelsey Lovett for being such an amazing human and friend to Allie and for using her platform for those who are victims and survivors of Domestic Violence! Also, a lot of the information for this episode came from her Facebook page.