Send us Fan Mail

The fastest way to unlock a whole childhood is to say two words: Trapper Keeper. We’re on the eve of a new school year, and we end up doing a back-to-school nostalgia “best of” that turns into a surprisingly intense debate about the school supplies that mattered way more than they should have. From the legendary folder setups to the humble pencil that still felt like treasure, we relive the tiny status symbols that shaped elementary and middle school life in the 1980s and 1990s.

We get specific, because that’s where the memories live: NFL pencils from the school office vending machine, the never-ending wide-ruled vs. college-ruled argument, pencil brands you either loved or hated, and the strange reality that some kids had the 128-count crayon box with the built-in sharpener while others were making “peach” by mixing whatever broken colors were left. We also talk adhesive choices like rubber cement and musilage, pencil boxes, and the kind of DIY creativity that shows up when you don’t have the “good” stuff.

Then we hit the cafeteria classics. Packed lunches, brown bags, thermoses, field trip food, and the hall-of-fame school lunch menu items that no adult version can truly recreate, including the rectangle pizza that still haunts our taste buds. Along the way we share a few school stories that range from funny to genuinely frustrating, including punishments, bathroom rules, and the kind of teacher feedback that sticks for decades.

If you grew up loving school supplies, hating them, or just trying to make it to lunch, you’ll feel seen. Subscribe, share this with a friend who still remembers their lunchbox, and leave a review if it made you laugh. What was your one must-have back-to-school item?