Cover of Worse Than Nothing

Worse Than Nothing

The Dangerous Fallacy of Originalism

Sample
Season's Savings

0.99 €/mo for 3 months

Auto-renews at 5.99 €/month after 3 months. Cancel monthly.
Get this deal
Offer ends on 28 December, 2026.
More purchase options

Worse Than Nothing

By: Erwin Chemerinsky
Narrated by: Daniel Henning
Get this deal

Auto-renews at 5.99 €/month after 3 months. Cancel monthly. Offer ends 28 December, 2026.

Buy Now for €15.48

Buy Now for €15.48

Season's Savings | 0.99 €/month for 3 months

5.99 €/month thereafter - terms apply. Cancel monthly.
Summary

Why originalism is a flawed, incoherent, and dangerously ideological method of constitutional interpretation

Originalism, the view that the meaning of a constitutional provision is fixed when it is adopted, was once the fringe theory of a few extremely conservative legal scholars but is now a well-accepted mode of constitutional interpretation. Three of the Supreme Court's nine justices explicitly embrace the originalist approach, as do increasing numbers of judges in the lower courts.

Noted legal scholar Erwin Chemerinsky gives a comprehensive analysis of the problems that make originalism unworkable as a method of constitutional interpretation. He argues that the framers themselves never intended constitutional interpretation to be inflexible and shows how it is often impossible to know what the "original intent" of any particular provision was. Perhaps worst of all, though its supporters tout it as a politically neutral and objective method, originalist interpretation tends to disappear when its results fail to conform to modern conservative ideology.

©2022 Erwin Chemerinsky (P)2022 Tantor
Political Science Politics & Government World
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet