Series low point, but still far better than most.

Story: huge blocks of exposition drug it down Performance: while some voices were spot on (Murillio for example), some were incredibly inappropriate, showing a lack of understanding of the characters. Also a lack of range for the large cast.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Good, but my least favorite of the series

What made the experience of listening to Toll the Hounds the most enjoyable?

The Narrator is very good and by book 8, I have gotten comfortable with his style and delivery. The pace and tone are good and the book itself has a decent pacing so part of his job is done for him.

How would you have changed the story to make it more enjoyable?

This is book 8 in a 10 book series. It is, so far, my least favorite of the series. I actually read the books starting in the 1990s but had to get them from the UK which meant long periods of time between books.

I bought the series from Audible to listen to them in order, back to back. I have found that in doing so, subtle parts that I missed when reading the books so many years ago, I pick up on now.

They are all great, but this is my least favorite of the series. The book tells parts of the story from inconsistent points of view (in my opinion) which is not bad, but not as smooth as the earlier stories. Still, a good read, but just a different style than the other 7 books.

What does Michael Page bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

If you are listening to the series, by book 8 you are very comfortable with Michael's style and you recognize characters by voice. When I read the books, I sometimes had a hard time keeping the many, many characters straight. Especially if time had elapsed between my reading.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

It is very difficult to do this given it is a 40 hour commitment. I do find myself trying to get to the end of a chapter or looking forward to a serious block of time when I can listen for a few hours at once.

Any additional comments?

This is a great series. While this is not my favorite book, I have both read and listened to it. I still highly recommend the book and the series.

4 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

What?

I mean it followed the slow build of the others, which I like, but I felt like I didn’t have a clue what was happening the whole time. Things would just happen and plot would go unexplained until the last hour. So many details. So many characters. Hope the next one’s more plot driven.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Anti-climactic

While the series continues to build toward it's climactic end, the climax of this book itself is a bit lackluster. Several events that have were heavily foreshadowed throughout the book are given only light treatment, or dealt with by characters other than those who are most affected by them, leaving the reader feeling cheated and dissatisfied with the resolution of those conflicts. It's still a fantastic novel, but it isn't quite up to the level of the other books in the series.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

long painful and amazing.

This was hard to get through. but the ending made it all worth it. just... yeah......

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

struggled to finish....

I really liked the previous volumes in the series. This one leaves me wondering. Wondering why so much prose and poetry were necessary between segments.... running out of storyline, probably not, but it's way too much used as filler.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Soooooo Wordy but Worth It

Let's start with the cons: it appears that Steven tried his hand as a poet… he was not successful. I could've done without all the fanciful narration.
Pros: good plot development, tied up a lot of loose ends, and of course he created some questions to be answered in the next book but that is a good thing. Very intense and exciting ending. On a final note I think Michael Page gets better by each book he does and his performance really sells the story.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Brilliant

I have loved this series since I picked up the first book, book 8 is no exception, once you start it is hard to stop and take a break.
The narrator does some characters justice, Iskaral Pust is in my mind perfectly portrayed, while Anomander Rake sounds like an old manservant.

All things considered The malazan book of the fallen is the best high fantasy out there, from The black Company to The wheel of time and A song of fire and ice.

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Just stays good!

I love fantasy series, but I find they "burn out" and get tedious or repetitive, and end up going longer than they should. 8 books in, I'm still jazzed for each new chapter! I am really astounded that I let the first book hold me back from this series for so long! (Clarification: great book too, just requires you to take it seriously; not a weekend reader).

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Series continues to impress

So much has been said about the Malazan series that I'm going to limit myself to a couple of personal impressions & some thoughts about the narrators.

The length of the Malazan Book of the Fallen series gave the author broad-range opportunities for developing complex characters, and he took full advantage of the big canvass. Few of them change in a linear way and a lot of times my feelings reverse and reverse again while continuing to connect with a character.

Erikson usually approaches philosophical and spiritual issues by keeping discussions open-ended, leaving readers with enough substance to continue chewing on the questions raised. I was disappointed in a couple of sections towards the end of Toll the Hounds that were more like closed little packages. The rest of the book was good enough to keep me from knocking off any stars.

In reviews of the other books, there's been a lot of discussion about the narrators. Their styles are quite different & I generally like both. I agree with listeners who have said there should be more than one narrator for each book. There are just too many characters, creating a need for more unique voices than one individual can handle. Both narrators were particularly Inadequate re. women's voices. Also, in order to broaden the range of voices, both of them resorted to styles that were growly, creaky, etc, that get old very quickly. It would have been much better to have at minimum a male & a female narrator for each book,

One of my biggest frustrations with both narrators has been that neither of them pause at all between the sections of a chapter. There's no indication that we've moved from one plot-line to another, which can lead to a lot of unnecessary rewinding.

Hope I haven't sounded too negative-- I'm really enjoying the series. Definitely recommended!

2 personnes ont trouvé cela utile