It kept me guessing!!

I pre-ordered One of Us is Lying by Karen M. McManus because right away it sounded like an episode out of Gossip Girl (and I'm telling you, I loved Gossip Girl!). I also liked that there were multiple narrators, which I haven't experienced too much in audiobooks. I'm glad I spent the credit on this book, and if you like teen drama or the "whodunit" type mysteries, you will enjoy it as well.

I couldn't decide whether to give it 4 or 5 stars. If I could, I'd have to settle on a 4.5 rating. I liked the fact that there were 4 narrators for 4 different main characters, but even though there were only 4 of them, it seemed like I got lost a bit keeping track of 'who was who' & 'who did what.' When you listen, make sure you pay attention to detail or you might get lost as other people are introduced into the story. I tried to multi-task while listening, and I found myself wondering what was going on in some places, mostly because my mind wasn't fully focusing on the story....learn from my mistake. I plan to listen to it again to get the full experience, even though I know how the murder of the 5th student happened. I liked it so much that I don't mind...plus I'm sure I'll come across a bunch of details that I overlooked the first time through. :-)

I thought both the writing and narration were great! It's told in alternating points of view by each of the 4 teens. Throughout the entire story I was thinking I knew who the murderer was. It wasn't until the last part that I realized I was totally off base. Wow! I didn't expect that one at all! It kept me guessing.

I recommend this audiobook to those who like mysteries, drama, and teen characters. It's not a thriller, nor is it an "edge of your seat" read; it is just a really good murder mystery that starts right away and ends 10+ hours later. It kept my interest throughout, and I felt like I got to know each of the kids well. It was a mix of Gossip Girl (TV show) and Clue (the movie & boardgame)....might be a bad comparision, but just know I used to LOVE them both! :-) I definitely think it is worth the credit, and I am looking forward to listening to it again in the future!

Thank you for reading my review. :-)

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

48 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Teenage love story NOT murder mystery

"One of us is lying" is a misleading title for this book... unless you consider the author or the title itself as the "one" that is lying. this book is more of a teenage love story rather than a murder mystery. It's not bad as far as story goes, but IF you are hoping for a murder mystery for your road trip, and you don't want to listen about teenagers love lives for hours this book is not for you.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

46 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Big Car No Gas

Would you ever listen to anything by Karen M. McManus again?

Probably not

What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?

At first, I wasn't in love with the voice acting. It took listening to a chapter or two before I realized what grated on me most. It has less to do with the voice actors and more to do with the director/producer of the audio book. The voice actors were fine, in fact, probably perfectly cast for the roles of the characters they played. What was unfair to them was that they were given the task of not only narrating their own character's voice but the other characters as well during their narratives. This meant that 4 different voice actors had to provide the voice of Nate. Four different actors had to cover Addy and so on. This would have been MUCH better had the producer/director allowed the actor who voiced his/her character to do so EACH TIME no matter which of the four characters were narrating. Continuity guys...

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

SLIGHT SPOILER ALERTJust disappointed...This is a classic example of an author who has a promising idea but not the ability to carry it out. Entrepreneur with the big idea but no engineering to bring it to life.

THE GOOD
The premise of the book was exciting. I found it during it's pre release phase and, based on the brief description given, I was hooked and found myself thinking about it every few days up to its release. Obviously a nod to John Hughes with a twist, the idea was a strong. Five kids go into detention and only four leave - a modern setting for the age-old "who dunnit".

The storyline between characters was good. There were enough surprises and unique pieces added to each characters backstory to make them interesting and modern. There were plenty of details dropped to follow. These, however, were more like lines and less like red herrings. No idea challenged you to mentally chase it. You just added it to inventory of things to keep up with.

THE BAD
The killer was pretty easy to guess - no real shock.

The killer's accomplice, however, was horribly written (the biggest disappointment for me) and COULD have been so much better. NOTHING in the story provided any background that would have led me to believe this character would have gone to the extremes written. Ridiculous. This character was so wrapped up in himself...he would NOT have done this.

In fact, it was so far fetched, that I initially thought it was an incredibly clever deception by the author. It was, however, a flat delivery and felt like a rushed exit. I had no feelings for the accomplice but no belief in his actions either.

The other thing that bugged me were the narratives. These are high school kids providing a narrative that vacillated between a believable "high school kid" and an omniscient narrative that just felt out of place. The kids provided too detailed and at times too mature/dramatic descriptions for the age of their characters.

Final things. SPOILER ALERT FROM HERE ON

There were stereotypes and cliche points to the letter for some characters. Lot's of "girl power" written in the story too without the need. Guy's humbly submitting themselves to the girls who are in control (Ashtyn and Bronwyn) when they've done nothing to deserve the power they've been given.

Addy gets a dismissive "pass" on sleeping around but Bronwyn makes Nate "pay" for not speaking to her/breaking up with her after he is released from jail? Um...yeah...

So, what COULD have made this spectacular?

Just a few simple things:

1) The voice actors should have been allowed to voice their characters when called to speak in each person's narrative.

2) A little more realistic narrative from the high school kids. They are high school kids narrating their feelings not romance novelists trying to poetically describe the world around them.

3) Had Jenea (sp? I purchased the audible book and not the actual book to check the spelling) been the killer (or at least the accomplice) she could have been lying to Addy about Jake to frame him. During the time she was confronted by Addy and was confirming Jake's role, I really believed the author had created an INCREDIBLE twist and that Addy would have believed Jake was the accomplice when it was really Jenea. THAT would have been an awesome twist showing that Jenea had been jilted by Simon and she had masterminded everything while throwing suspicion on everyone (including Jake). When I learned that was NOT the case, the rating when from 5+ to 2 at best.

The big car was entertaining but just ran out of gas...

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

30 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Thoroughly Engrossing

For Karen McManus’s first novel, she dives into the world of high schoolers faced with typical challenges like college applications, sports, and dating. However, these particular teenagers have a less-than-common problem – they are all under investigation for murder. As the story of four unlikely partners in crime unravels, you’ll be guessing right until the very end – whodunit? Four narrators tell the story from each point of view, giving you a real feel for each of the main characters. A blend of The Breakfast Club meets Pretty Little Liars, One of Us is Lying is a thoroughly engrossing YA novel that won’t let you put your headphones down.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

14 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Unknowing Witness or Murder Mastermind?

This is a high school mystery filled with guilt, heart and is complete with so many dirty little secrets. I could not stop listening to this story once I started. I gobbled it up rather quickly. It is one part fun, many parts drama and at times very scary. I have come to really enjoy the young adult genre and after being out of high school for some time now I believe this story has the characters with just enough sass, vulnerability and minimum life experience to be realistic. This is written with multiple POV and gives different vantage points of the story. I really liked this as it was performed by a full cast giving the character’s all distinct voices. The characters are sneaky and this book proves that you never know what goes on behind closed doors. There are definitely stereotypes throughout the book, but that is expected because who’s high school didn’t have them? At times the plot does feel like it has been done before but then out come the under lying teenage themes of the pressure to succeed, wanting to be liked and a whole lot of self reflection. Let’s not even mention the mystery that I was endlessly trying to figure out. The narration was just amazing and I could not pick a favourite performance if I tried. The Southern accented Cooper or the soft spoken Addy, hard nosed Nate or last but certainly not least sophisticated Bronwyn each bring distinct flavour to this story. Each has moments of anger, sadness and happiness which each narrator captures perfectly. A great listening experience.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

7 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

My primary criticism is partially my mistake

Any additional comments?

As I started listening, I very soon felt that "The Breakfast Club", and, more so, John Hughes should have shared the credits. Bronwyn/Claire, Nate/John, Cooper/Andrew, and to some extent Addy/Allison. Even the parents shared character traits with those in that film. What I failed to note before purchasing was that this book is geared to teens. Teens today don't even know "The breakfast Club", as it came out in '85. I still call a bit of plagiarism on the part of the author, but knowing it was intended for teens diluted my other irritations with the storyline. I stayed with it to the end, didn't see the plot twist coming, and overall don't regret my time. Glad I got it on a daily deal, though.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

5 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

So dark, surprised people like this for young teen

I read this with my 14 year old daughter and wow, so dark. The writing is decent. Even on common sense media they do not correctly describe the amount of sex, drinking, swearing. I am not sure who exactly is the positive character for a young teen reader. There is not one person who has much redeeming. I understand much of these issues are common for some teens, but the degree of sex, drinking, abusive relationships and then ending in death well that seems to be on one end of the spectrum. I certainly hope the teens who read this see that there are alternatives to this lifestyle and these choices. Very disturbing.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Skip this

The book itself is a pretty weak YA novel. The so called suspense at the core is very predictable. But worse are the characters: they all are stereotypes but don’t really have many unique characteristics — very very weak. The narration was also very bad - one man couldn’t do an accent, they each couldn’t do the other gender. And worse they all spoke with the same tone so it was easy to confuse who was supposed to be talking.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Interesting

The story starts with a group of kids serving detention for having cell phones in class but before detention is over, one kid has a medical emergency and dies which turns everyone else into suspects. This story follows the other kids and exposes their deepest secrets all before exposing the deepest of all. Interesting to see who actually killed Simon and why. A lot of twists and turns and shows that everything is not always as it seems.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile

Great Book!

I loved this book. I couldn't wait to finish it. the story kept me on my toes and the performance for very believable. I didn't expect a lot from this book so it was a pleasant surprise.

Merci. Votre vote a été pris en compte.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation !

3 personnes ont trouvé cela utile